Credit and Finance Risk Analysis - www.credfinrisk.com

  Money Market Instruments and Short-Term Funds Bookmark and Share CredFinRisk.com

  Selected Interest Rates, Federal Reserve

  Wall Street Journal Money Rates

  Bloomberg Key Rates


On Tuesday, December 16, 2008, the Federal Open Market Committee of the U.S. Federal Reserve lowered the Fed Funds rate to a record low of a range of zero to 0.25%.   www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/press/monetary/20081216b.htm

On March 5, 2009, the Monetary Policy Committee of the Bank of England lowered the Base Rate to a record low of 0.50% (the lowest rate since the bank commenced operation in 1694).
www.bankofengland.co.uk/publications/news/2009/019.htm


On September 19, 2008,the U.S. Treasury Department has established a Temporary Guarantee Program for Money Market Funds. Under this program, the U.S. Treasury will guarantee to investors that they will receive $1 for each money market fund share held as of close of business on September 19, 2008. Eligible funds must be regulated under Rule 2a-7 of the Investment Company Act of 1940, must maintain a stable share price of $1 and must be publicly offered and registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Both taxable and non-taxable funds are eligible for this program.
www.treas.gov/offices/domestic-finance/key-initiatives/money-market-fund.shtml

On October 21, 2008, the Federal Reserve Board announced the creation of the Money Market Investor Funding Facility (MMIFF), under Section 13(3) of the Federal Reserve Act, which authorizes the Federal Reserve Bank of New York (FRBNY) to provide senior secured funding to a series of special purpose vehicles to facilitate an industry-supported private-sector initiative to finance the purchase of eligible assets from eligible investors. Eligible assets will include U.S. dollar-denominated certificates of deposit and commercial paper issued by highly rated financial institutions and having remaining maturities of 90 days or less. Eligible investors will include U.S. money market mutual funds and over time may include other U.S. money market investors.
www.newyorkfed.org/markets/mmiff.html

On October 7, 2008, the Federal Reserve Board announced the creation of the Commercial Paper Funding Facility (CPFF), a facility that will complement the Federal Reserve's existing credit facilities to help provide liquidity to term funding markets. The CPFF authorizes the Federal Reserve Bank of New York (FRBNY) to provide a liquidity backstop to U.S. issuers of commercial paper through a special purpose vehicle (SPV) that will purchase three-month unsecured and asset-backed commercial paper directly from eligible issuers. The Federal Reserve will provide financing to the SPV under the CPFF and will be secured by all of the assets of the SPV and, in the case of commercial paper that is not asset-backed commercial paper, by the retention of up-front fees paid by the issuers or by other forms of security acceptable to the Federal Reserve in consultation with market participants.
www.newyorkfed.org/markets/cpff.html

On September 19, 2008 the Federal Reserve Board announced the creation of the Asset Backed Commercial Paper Money Market Mutual Fund Liquidity Facility (AMLF), which extends loans to all U.S. depository institutions, bank holding companies (parent companies or U.S. broker-dealer affiliates), or U.S. branches and agencies of foreign banks to purchase asset backed commercial paper from money market mutual funds.
www.frbdiscountwindow.org/mmmftc.cfm?hdrID=14&dtlID


The difference between money market investments and capital market investments is that money market investments usually have a term of one year or less, while capital market transactions have a duration that exceeds one year. A further definition is that money market instruments can be converted to cash rather quickly and have a low risk profile due to the short maturity.

There is both a primary market (first issue) and secondary market for money market instruments, however there is no formal Exchange for the listing and trading of money market instruments. Rather, the primary participants in the money market consist of commercial banks, governments, corporations, government-sponsored enterprises (Farm Credit System, Federal Home Loan Bank System, Federal National Mortgage Association, Government National Mortgage Association), money market mutual funds, futures market exchanges, brokers and dealers, and the Federal Reserve.

Money market transactions can be done by "name give-up" / introducing broker or through an intermeidiary. In a name give-up transaction, all portions of the transaction are anonymous through an OTC electronic screen-based system until the very end when the two parties identify themselves for the purpose of settling the transaction. It is at that point that credit risk is assumed between the two participants. In an intermediary transaction the operator or broker in an OTC screen-based system will be the counterparty to other parties (who remain anonymous) and will then match back-to-back transactions.

Money Market Instruments (and the corresponding interest rate) consist of:
  • Federal Funds (Federal Funds Rate)
  • Overnight Repurchase Agreement Rate
  • Discount Window (Discount Rate)
  • Euro Overnight Index Average (Eonia) / Sterling Overnight Index Average (SONIA)
  • Certificates of Deposit / CD (Prevailing CD market rates)
  • Eurodollar Deposit / CD (LIBOR)
  • Bank Prime Loan (Prime Rate)
  • Banker's Acceptances (Discount yield)
  • Commercial Paper (isued by non-financial corporations and financial institutions)
  • Euro Commercial Paper (Discount yield)
    Dealer Commercial Paper
  • Repurchase Agreement
  • Treasury Bill (Discount yield)
  • Auction Rate securities (ARS)


  • Federal Funds / Federal Funds Rate

      Daily Fed Funds Effective Rate, Federal Reserve Bank of New York

      Historic Fed Funds Rates, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

      Fed Funds Rate Predictions, Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland


    The Federal Funds Rate is often utilized by the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve, Open Market Committee, to either stimulate or curtail economic expansion. For instance, in response to the tightening of the credit markets and growing recession during 2008, the Fed Funds Rate was reduced six times.

    Recent Fed Funds Rates
    DateFed funds Rate
    December 16, 20080.00% - 0.25%
    October 29, 20081.00%
    October 8, 20081.50%
    April 30, 20082.00%
    March 18, 20082.25%
    January 30, 20083.00%
    January 22, 20083.50%

    Source  http://www.ny.frb.org/markets/statistics/dlyrates/fedrate.html

    Some depository institutions are reguired to maintain a reserve account with its district Federal Reserve Bank. Every two weeks there is a Reserve Account Settlement Day when each bank must reconcile the actual amount in its reserve account with the reserve requirement from the previous two weeks. In order to comply with that requirement the bank must have sufficient reserves in the account or arrange for a short-term, overnight loan deposited into the reserve account. Thus, Federal funds are overnight, unsecured loans between two financial institutions used to satisfy Federal Reserve overnight reserve requirements. Banks that have excess funds in their reserve account are lenders to those banks that have a reserve deficiency. These funds are normally transferred within the time frame of a single business day in order to meet reserve requirements (usually a debit to the lending bank's account at the district Federal Reserve Bank and a credit to the account of the borrowing bank). There are also broker banks that consolidate excess reserves from several banks and then arrange to lend the balance to those banks that require additional reserves. Fed funds can be borrowed by only those depository institutions that are required by the Monetary Control Act of 1980 to hold reserves with Federal Reserve Banks. The interest rate at which banks lend these funds to each other is the Federal Funds Rate, which is set by the Federal Reserve (as a part of monetary policy). These overnight transactions are usually unsecured between banks that already have correspondent banking relationships. Longer term federal funds loans (term loans with a fixed maturity and continuing contract, which are perpetually rolled over until either parties terminate) usually have formal written agreements. In the event that a bank has a reserve deficiency and perhaps it is too late in the day to arrange for a loan at the Federal Funds rate or the rate has increased to an unacceptable level, the bank may then borrow from the Federal Reserve Discount Window (see next).

    In addition to bank to-bank federal funds, some banks will also issue overnight repurchase agreements (take in cash and issue an acceptable security as collateral, which the bank repurchases the following day and returns the cash) in order to obtain funds from corporate and municipal treasury departments that have extra liquidity but are structurally barred from being participants in the fed funds market. As many banks are all competiting for funds at the same time in order to satisfy reserve account requirements, this non-bank overnight funds market is essential and the Repurchase Agreement Rate closely mirrors the Fed Funds Rate (the repurchase rate is slightly lower due to the collateralized structure of a repurchase agreement transaction).

    Why is the actual Daily Fed Funds rate often lower than the Target Fed Funds rate? When banks have excess reserves over their required minimum amount, which does not earn interest, they lend the extra cash and that activity places downward pressure on the federal funds rate.



    Discount Window (Federal Reserve Bank) / Discount Rate

    Short-term funds lent by the Federal Reserve to banks at the Discount Rate, which is also set by the Federal Reserve (as part of monetary policy). Each depository institution (commercial, community, savings and loan, etc.) located within a respective district of one of the 12 Federal Reserve Banks is required to maintain a reserve account with that District bank. When a depository institution determines that is has a insufficient amount of reserves on-hand, the institution may borrow additional funds from the Federal Reserve Discount Window in order to increase the reserve account to the proper level. Typically, borrowings (which are actually credits to the institution's reserve account with the district Fedral Reserve Bank) from the Discount Window are for an overnight period in order to meet the reserve requirement and then the institution goes into the market to attract deposits, issue CDs or sell securities from its portfolio in order to pay off the borrowings from the Federal Reserve. The term Discount Window is from an earlier period when all advances from the Federal Reserve were collateralized by the "discounted" value of a pledged asset from the borrowing institution. Now, all Discount Window advances are collateralized by an approved list of eligible collateral.

    The Federal Reserve Discount Window is suppose to be "Lender of Last Resort" when an institution has insufficient reserves on account with the Federal Reserve. The Discount Rate is usually lower than the Fed Funds Rate and borrowing from the Discount Window is sometime seen as an indication that the financial institution (Borrower) is in some type of trouble. The Fed encourages the bank to have sufficient reserves through deposit inflows and / or borrowing in the Fed Funds market. In addition to depository institutions that offer traditional savings and checking accounts, depository institutions that maintain transaction accounts such as checking and NOW accounts or nonpersonal time deposits may also borrow from the Discount Window if necessary. In addition, the Fed may lend to the U.S. branches and agencies of foreign banks if they hold deposits against which reserves must be kept. In the event that the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System determine that there are unusual conditions that have placed the finacial markets under pressure and traditional credit sources are unavailable, then individuals, partnerships, and corporations that are not depository institutions may be granted access to the Discount Window.

    As indicated above, borrowings from the Discount Window are normally overnight duration to adjust the reserve account balance. These advances are known as Adjustment credit. The Federal Reserve Discount Window will also provide longer term advances known as Extended credit. Extended credit is only granted to acommodate seasonal financial activities that are naturally occurring within the bank's region (for instance agricultural activity) or when there are conditions beyond the control of the bank that effect capital (for instance natural disasters or adverse economic conditions). The Extended advance is usually for a maximum of 60 days maximum within a 120-day period, and institutions termed undercapitalized by a regulatory agency may only borrow from the Discount Window for a maximum of 5 days.

    Financial institutions are not permitted to borrow from the Federal Reserve Discount Window lower Discount Rate to obtain sufficient funds to meet reserve requirements and simultaneously lend excess funds to other institutions at the higher Fed Funds Rate.



    Bank of England Base Rate

      Bank of England Official Bank Rate history

    The Base Rate is set by the Monetary Policy Committee of the Bank of England. The Base Rate is the official Bank Rate paid by the Bank of England on commercial bank reserves.



    Euro Overnight Index Average (Eonia / Euronia) / Sterling Overnight Index Average (SONIA)

      Eonia Historical Rates

      SONIA Historical Rates, Wholesale Markets Brokers' Association

    Eonia (Euro OverNight Index Average) is the effective overnight reference rate for the euro. It is computed as a weighted average of all overnight unsecured lending transactions undertaken in the interbank market, initiated within the euro area by the contributing banks: all specified transactions initiated during the business day shall be reported by the Panel Banks in aggregate, i.e. the sum of all lending transactions carried out before the closing of real-time gross settlement (RTGS) systems at 6.00 p.m. (CET).

    There is also the Sterling Overnight Index Average (SONIA), which is a U.K. referance rate from the Wholesale Markets Brokers' Association. As per the WMBA, "SONIA is the weighted average rate to four decimal places of all unsecured sterling overnight cash transactions brokered in London by WMBA member firms between midnight and 4.15pm with all counterparties in a minimum deal size of £25 million."



    Certificates of Deposit (CDs) / CD Rate

      1-Month Certificate of Deposit: Secondary Market Rate, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

      3-Month Certificate of Deposit: Secondary Market Rate, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

      6-Month Certificate of Deposit: Secondary Market Rate, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

    There are personal or savings CDs, which are debt instruments with a fixed rate of return (there are also variable rate CDs offered) and term, usually purchased by individuals seeking a safe investment (bank-issued CDs are FDIC insured up to USD$100,000). Savings CDs are usually offered with a stated interest rate based on a minimum deposit for a stated term. However, there are discounted CDs (sold at a discount to the face value of the CD). CD maturities can range from 3-month, 6-month and one year to over one year. Principal and accrued interest are due on the maturity date. Most CDs are structured that they may not be redeemed prior to the maturity date without paying a penalty. CD investments are also approved for IRA plans.

    Negotiable Certificates of Deposit are certificates of time deposit accounts at a commercial bank. They range in denominations from USD$100,000 to in excess of USD$1,000,000. They are referred to as "negotiable" as the party investing the cash into the CD may negotiate a slightly higher inteest rate due to the high amouint of the deposit. These CDs are sometimes arranged by a broker who can consolidate cash investments and negotiate an improved interest rate. The maturities are unlimited, however money market instruments are less than one year in maturity. There is a good secondary market for these CDs and the holder of the CD can discount it to another party in order to raise cash. The rate of a negotiable CD is based on a yield basis, and it is based on actual days for a 360 day year. Interest and principal are paid at maturity.



    Eurodollar / LIBOR

      Euribor Current & Historical Rates

      Historic LIBOR Rates, British Banker's Association


    The unsecured interbank lending market experienced disruption during 2008 due to the loss of confidence in many financial institutions with regard to the quality of an institution's on-balance sheet assets. Historically the spread between Libor and the federal funds rate has been 10 basis points. However, after August 2007, the spread began to widen as the uncertainty rose about the liquidity and solvency of banks. The widening of the spread persisted throughout 2008 until conditions in the interbank lending market deteriorated substantially by October 2008, with the spread widening to over 300 basis points. The condition resulted in the Federal Reserve Board introducing a new programs in October 2008 designed to alleviate some of the pressure in the interbank lending market.

    Eurodollar deposits are deposits denominated in USD but are deposited outside the legal jurisdiction (and banking regulation) of the United States (the most actively traded offshore deposit). They are sometimes referred to as offshore deposits and can really be any deposits placed outside the country of denomination. The other Euro-deposits are the Japanese yen, U.K. sterling, Swiss francs and Canadian dollars (and the Euro outside of the EU). In the United Kingdom, certain banks accept dollar deposits with set maturities (usually 90 days) and the interest rate is LIBOR (London Interbank Offered Rate).



    Prime Rate

    Prime Rate, or the Bank Prime Loan rate, is the rate posted by 75% of top 35 (by assets in domestic offices) insured U.S.-chartered commercial banks. Prime is one of several base rates used by banks to price short-term business loans and is also used in consumer financial products. Prime Rate changes tends to mirror changes in the Federal Funds Rate (Fed Funds + 3.0%)

    Recent Prime Rates
    DatePrime Rate
    December 16, 20083.25%
    October 29, 20084.00%
    October 8, 20084.50%
    April 30, 20085.00%
    March 18, 20085.25%
    January 30, 20086.00%
    January 22, 20086.50%
    December 11, 20077.25%
    October 31, 20077.50%
    September 18, 20077.75%
    June 29, 20068.25%
    May 10, 20068.00%
    March 28, 20067.75%

    Source  research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/data/PRIME.txt




    U.S. Treasury Bills

      Daily Treasury Bill Rates, U.S. Treasury

      4-Week Treasury Bill: Secondary Market Rate, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

      3-Month Treasury Bill: Secondary Market Rate, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

      6-Month Treasury Bill: Secondary Market Rate, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

    Treasury Bills (T-Bill) are short-term U.S. Treasury issues of one week to 12 months. They are purchased at a discount to their face value (but pay face value at maturity) in what as known as a yield auction. In a yield auction the potential purchasers indicate the yield / discount to face value that they are willing to pay at that given moment in order to own the T-Bill. The bidder with the least discount of the face value of the T-Bill wins the auction. There is a very active secondary market for the buying and selling of T-Bills, and they are also used as collateral in repurchase agreement transactions.



    Banker's Acceptances

    The usage of Banker's Acceptances occur primarily in international trade. An Importer (Drawer) enters into an Acceptance Agreement with their primary bank (Drawee) in order to facilitate a transaction in which the Importer cannot obtain financing from an overseas Exporter. A Banker's Acceptance is a time draft drawn on and accepted by a banking institution which substitutes its credit for that of an importer and is guaranteed by a bank as to payment. This is a Documentary Collection payment method (Time Draft / Documents against Acceptance), in which the shipped goods become available before payment, payment is made on the maturity of the draft, the payment of the draft is reliant upon the Importer paying.

    Essentially:
  • The Importer has a banking relationship with a bank already
  • The importer arranges for a shipment from an Exporter
  • A bank draft is a draft or a check drawn by a bank on itself, which it marks as Accepted
  • The bank issues the Banker's Acceptance on the behalf of the Importer and if the documentation is correct then the bank pays the Exporter
  • The Banker's Acceptance has a maturity of 30 to 270 days
  • It is the obligation of the Importer to repay the Banker's Acceptance
  • The bank can sell the Banker's Acceptance at a discount to an investor in the secondary market for such instruments in order to obtain the cash today
  • The Importer repays the Banker's Acceptance to the holder
  • There is a very good secondary market in these products with institutional investors and money market funds, however they are beginning to be replaced by alternative methods and products. They typically range in denominations from USD$25,000 to USD$1,000,000. These are sold discounted in actual days based on a 360 day year.



    Commercial Paper

      Commercial Paper Rates and Outstanding, Federal Reserve

      1-Month AA Financial Commercial Paper Rate, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

      1-Month AA Non-Financial Commercial Paper Rate, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


    The commercial paper market experienced disruption during 2008 due to lower demand from money market mutual funds, which experienced massive net outflows from investor redemptions. Commercial paper rates increased substantially in late September 2008, which resulted in the Federal Reserve Board introducing three new programs in October 2008, designed to alleviating some of the pressure in the commercial paper market.

    Commercial Paper is a short-term unsecured promissory note primarily issued by non-financial corporations, while banks issue bank note or bank paper and finance companies issue paper directly to institutional investors or through commercial paper dealers and it is a low cost alternative to bank loans. Interest rates on commercial paper are entirely market derived and are reflective of the credit worthiness of the issuer. Many corporations have 364-day revolving credit facility back-up commitments from banks in order to credit enhance the commercial paper program. In the event that the commercial paper can't be rolled over / funded at a reasonable rate, the comapny will draw on the credit facility to pay off the investors in the commercial paper and the company will then have a substitute bank loan.

    In the United States, the commercial paper market is very large. It is very active as the issuance of commercial paper under the terms of Section 3(a)(3) of the 1933 Securities Act exempts these short-term securities from the expensve and time consuming registration process. Commercial paper may not exceed 270 days in maturity (average maturity is 30 to 35 days).

    The benchmark commercial paper program is from General Electric Capital Corporation (GECC). Tier 1 corporate issuers like GECC obtain the best financing. There is also Asset Backed Commercial Paper (ABCP), which is used to fund (and is collateralized by) a group of assets. Issuers who are rated A2 / P2 by the credit rating agencies have a harder time of obtaining funding at attractive rates.

    Prime Sales Finance Paper: These are promissory notes from finance companies placed directly with the investor. These come in denominations of $1,000 to $5,000,000. There is a minimum order of $25,000. These are issued to mature on any day ranging from 3 days to 270 days. There is no secondary market for these. Under certain conditions, the company will buy back the securities prior to maturity. They will usually adjust the interest rate in this event. These can be either discounted or interest bearing. And they are based on actual days based on a 360 day year.

    Dealer Paper (Finance): These are promissory notes of finance companies sold through commercial paper dealers. Their denominations range from $100,000 to $5,000,000. They are issued to mature on any day from 15 days to 170 days. There is a limited secondary market. Early buyback can usually be negotiated with the dealer. These can be either discounted or interest bearing based on actual days and a 360 day year.

    Dealer Paper (Industrial): These are promissory notes of the leading and largest industrial firms. It is sold through commercial paper dealers. They are sold in denominations of $500,000 to $5,000,000. They mature on certain dates form 30 days to 180 days. There is a limited secondary market. These are discounted based on actual days and a 360 day year.

    Euro Commercial Paper (ECP) are short-term, unsecured promissory notes, US dollar, Euro, British Pound, Swiss Franc, etc.-denominated issued outside the jurisdiction of the country of domicile of the isuer. The maturity can be from one to 365 days with most maturities between 30- to 180 days. The return on the ECP issue can either be interest bearing or is determined by the difference it is sold at a discount from the par value it will be redeemed at. ECP is either sold directly to investors (banks, institutional investors and corporate treasury desks) or through a dealer.



    Money Market Mutual Funds

    In late November, 2008, money market mutual funds (taxable and tax-free) reached a record total assets of $3.634 trillion. In mid-December 2008, money market mutual funds set a new record of approximately $3.8 trillion in total assets as cash was moved into the funds as a search for safety away from investments in the equity, bond and overseas markets. However, after the U.S. Federal Reserve Bank lowered the Fed Funds rate on December 16, 2008, to a record low of a range of zero to 0.25%, the funds began to see a withdrawal of investors cash as the yields on the funds themselves also began to approach zero. This was also considered problematic as the funds will not be able to generate sufficient income to cover fund expenses.

    Money Market funds are pooled cash investments from many individual and institutional investors. The funds are structured to invest in a diversified portfolio of very short-term, high grade / low-risk financial, corporate and governemnt debt. These funds can be either taxable or non-taxable based on their investments. Performance is usually presented in both weekly simple yield and weekly compound yield terms. These types of funds are an important cash management tool for corporations, institutions and individuals. Banks are also investors in money market accounts, either for their own investing / liquidity purposes or by offering money market accounts to depositors. Money Market funds are approved in the United States for both IRA and 401K investment plans.

    Money Market funds are professionally managed however the Manager has no access to the actual funds. Rather, the Manager just directs the allocation / investment of the funds in various types of financial instruments. The credit issue for the fund is that it must locate a sufficient number of high-grade debt issuers that will provide the return objective of the fund. The fund is usually managed to maintain a stable USD $1.00 value of each share (net asset value). The fund's prospectus will indicate the maximum maturity, minimum public credit rating and minimum diversification of the investments in the portfolio. Liquidity (for share redemption) is maintained by a minimum cash reserve, staggered maturities (of investments) and repo investments. Prior to 2008, the only fund in the past 20 years to fail to maintain the $1.00 net asset value of its fund shares was the Community Bankers U.S. Government Money Market Fund, which was liquidated and closed down at 96¢ on the dollar in 1994. The very first, and longest running (1970), money market mutual fund is the Primary Fund, managed by The Reserve, which on September 16, 2008, publicly indicated that the funds net asset value declined to 97¢ after Lehman Brothers filed for bankruptcy.

    The typical money market fund will invest in

  • Certificates of Deposit (London Branch, Eurododllar, Foreign Banks and New York Branch, Yankee Dollar, Foreign Banks)
  • Commercial Paper (Banks, Financial and Non-Financial, Asset-backed)
  • Federal Agencies/GSEs (GNMA, FNMA, FHLMC, FHLB)
  • Bank Notes
  • Master Notes
  • Medium-Term Notes
  • Short-Term Notes
  • Municipal Securities
  • Repurchase Agreements (Mortgage and Corporate Obligations).
  • The categories of Money Market Mutual Funds are Retail Prime, Government and Tax-Free, Institutional Prime, Government and Tax Free, and Offshore (not opened to investors residing in the United States).

    Money market funds are regulated under (17 CFR 270.2a-7). A money market fund may only hold Eligible Securities. An Eligible Security is a First Tier Security or Second Tier Security with a maturity of 397 days or less. To determine if a security is First Tier or Second Tier, we must first determine if it is a Rated Security. A Rated Security either (a) has received short-term ratings from NRSROs or (b) is comparable in priority and security to other obligations of the issuer that have received short-term ratings from NRSROs. A security that does not meet either criteria is an Unrated Security.



    Auction Rate Securities (ARS)

    This asset class includes municipal debt (non-taxable municipalities, non-profit hospitals, utilities, housing finance agencies, school districts, highway authorities; known as Municipal Auction-Rate Securities / MARS), student loan finance authorities (Student Loan-Backed Auction Rate Securities / SLARS), closed-end mutual funds, and to a lesser extent corporate debt (taxable). These single issue and asset-backed securities may not be registered or listed on a securities exchange and are instead sold to qualified institutional buyers under Rule 144A of the Securities Act. The auction period for these securities can be 7 days, 14 days, 28 days, 35 days and 49 days. The note interest rate (for the auction period) is also determined at auction (and then usually calculated on a 360-day year or 365-day year and the actual number of days elapsed during the related accrual period). Many of the municipal issuers do receive credit enhancement from the monoline bond insurers.

    The interest rate on the notes, which have a long-term nominal maturity (as long as 30 years), are determined periodically by means of a "Dutch Auction." In this Dutch Auction:

  • Investors and potential investors submit orders through an eligible broker-dealer as to the principal amount of auction rate notes they wish to buy or hold at a specified interest rate or the principal amount of auction rate notes that they wish to sell.
  • The broker-dealers submit their clients’ orders to the auction agent.
  • The auction agent processes all orders submitted by all eligible broker-dealers and determines the interest rate for the upcoming auction period.
  • The broker-dealers are notified by the auction agent of the interest rate for the upcoming auction period and are provided with settlement instructions relating to purchases and sales of auction rate notes.
  • Auction rate notes will be purchased and sold between investors and potential investors at par (at a price equal to their then-outstanding principal balance plus any accrued interest).
  • Initial purchasers of the securities or notes may not always be able to sell all or some of the notes when they want at auction if the auction "fails." A failed auction is when there are more notes offered for sale that there are buyers for those notes. In the event that the auction fails, the present note owner retains ownership until the next auction date (there is no obligation that the auction agent(s), usually commercial and investment banks, must purchase the notes from the present owner if the auction fails, nor is there any requirement that the issuer redeem the securities). In the event of a failed auction, the rate is set at a default rate specified in the prospectus, usually LIBOR plus a margin, or at market rate.

    Money market funds are ineligible to hold ARS due to Securities and Exchange Commission Rule 2a-7, restricting them to securities with a final maturity of 397 days or less.

    In February 2008, problems in the Auction Rate Securities market developed after a series of failed auctions.

  • The major issue is that purchasers claim that the investments may have been marketed as "cash equivalent" investments. However, investors were unable to get their funds back as there was no market for various ASR issues, hence investors are now in a longer-term investment than had been represented.
  • Secondly, due to the stalled market the ARS are resetting at the higher penalty rates, which are higher than similarly credit rated bonds thus the issuers now have a higher interest expense than may had been anticipated, and they may also be forced to redeem the security earlier then anticipated to avoid the higher rate.
  • Issuers are also being charged the annual auction transaction fee(s) by the financial institutions that operate the auctions although no actual auctions are taking place.
  • The issuer, to their advantage, may be able to redeem the issue at a discount in a secondary market. However, this creates an additional problem: it makes sense for the issuer to redeem the security at a discount but if the financial institution adviser assists with such a transaction, and the financial institution was also an adviser to the ARS purchaser who must now incur a loss to sell the security at a discount in the secondary market, then the financial institutions that marketed auction-rate securities as a cash equivalent investment have essentially proven that they are not similar to a cash equivilent investment by their own actions (these financial institutions would also have to mark-to-market any similar ARS they are holding on their balance sheet, which will not occur as long as the market remains stalled).


  • Return to Main Page



      Serving the Financial Industry

    Copyright © 2009 Credit and Finance Risk Analysis. All Rights Reserved.
    All corporate names and product names are the trademarks and/or registered trademarks of their respective owners.

    Bookmark and Share CredFinRisk.com