Quick Search Page:  
Credit and Finance Risk Analysis - www.credfinrisk.com

  Electric Power Industry & Electric Power Market Bookmark and Share CredFinRisk.com

  EuroPEX Rolling Month Average Daily Prices on the European Power Exchanges

  CME Group / NYMEX PJM Western Hub Peak Calendar Month Real Time LMP Swap Futures Contract

  CME Group / NYMEX PJM Western Hub 50 MW Peak Calendar Month Real Time LMP Swap Futures Contract

  EIA Average Retail Price of Electricity (by U.S. State; Cents per kilowatthour)

  EIA Electric Power Monthly

  EIA Electric Power Annual

  International Energy Agency (IEA) - Monthly Electricity Statistics



  Power Generation
 


Electricity

Electricity is a naturally occurring force. All matter is composed of the basic elements of the periodic table and of compounds (combinations of elements). These elements and compounds are composed of atoms. An atom consists of a positively charged nucleus (protons) which is surrounded by a negatively charged electron(s). Various unique combinations of the protons, electrons and neutrons (neutral particles) create the individual elements. An atom is held together by the forces of attraction between the negatively charged electrons and the positively charged protons. Most atoms tend to have the exact same amount of protons and electrons. However, some naturally occuring minerals / metals have electrons that have a weak bond and can be detached from the atom and become free electrons.

Copper is an ideal element to use for the production of electricity because it is a conductor. The copper atom has 29 protons and 29 electrons. The electrons surround the 29 proton nucleus in a series of shells, The first shell holds 2 electrons, the second shell holds up to 8 electrons, the third shell holds up to 18 electrons, and the next shell will hold up to 32 electrons. Copper has 28 electrons in its first three shells and the last remaining electron is alone in the outermost shell. This outermost electron has the least attraction to the nucleus due to its position. This free electron easily drifts from its original atom and attaches to a neighboring atom. In nature, the movement of the free electron is random. However, the design of the copper coil generator mentioned below is able to direct the movement of free electrons moving from atom to atom and this is electric current.

Generation is the production of electricity through mechanical energy, which in itself can be performed with assistance of the burning of fossil fuels or the use other energy sources. Most electricity generation in the world is produced at a fuel burning electric power plant. The power plant has large turbines, which are steel shafts that have numerous rows of blades, that are either turned by water (hydroelectric power generation), steam (created by burning coal or natural gas to heat water) or by engines that are powered by fossil fuels (natural gas, and transportation-grade petroleum distillates), and nuclear powered steam or engines. The turbine shaft has electromagnets attached to it (rotor) and these electromagnets spin rapidly within a cylindrical, magnet and copper coil housing (stator). The rotating magnetic field induces an alternating current within the stator, which is alternating current electricity. The rotor turns together with the turbine shaft at 3,000 revolutions per minute, or 50 revolutions per second, which corresponds to the 50 hertz (Hz) alternating current frequency of the electrical network (the direction of the current changes 50 times a second). The electricity is conducted away from the generator by voltage, along the copper wire and into a circuit, which must be closed and have one negative pole and one positive pole.

  • Electric Power (P) = Voltage (V) x Current (I; the amount of electrical flow)
  • Voltage measures electricity between 2 points within a curcuit.
  • Voltage (V) = Current (I) x Resistance (R; the measure of how easily electrical current flows through a substance; Resistance is encountered in all electrical transmission systems).
  • Electricity-generating capacity is measured in megawatts (MW); the electrical power generated by that capacity is measured in megawatt hours (MWh). During a full hour of operation, 1 MW of capacity produces 1 MWh of electricity, which can power roughly 800 average U.S. households.
  • The amount of electrical power required by an electric light or an electric appliance to operate is called wattage and is a function of the amount of current flowing through the wire (amperage), and the pressure in the system (voltage).
  • Volts x Amps = Watts
  • A 100 watt incandescent light bulb burning for 10 hours uses one kilowatt-hour (kWh), which is the basic unit for pricing electricity consumption. 1 kilowatt (1,000 watts) of power expended for 1 hour equal one kWh, which is also equivalent to 3,412 Btu or 3.6 million joules.
  • A 100 watt incandescent light bulb on a 120 volt / 50Hz electric circuit uses 0.83 amps of current to produce 100 watts of work.
  • The average residential circuit in the United States is a 120 volt / 50 Hz system and a 15 amp current, which means that a maximum of 1,800 watts (120 x 15) can flow through the circuit. If too many lights or applicances are operating on a single circuit then it can overheat or trip the circuit breaker. This is why there are several circuits in a residential or commercial property.
  • The size of electrical wire is dependent upon the amount of current required to flow through it to operate a specifc type of appliance (120 volts or 240 volts). Wire, wall outlet and circuit breaker components are designed to be compatible with each other in order to handle an anticipated electrical load (voltage and amperage).
  • All electric lines, electric cords and electric appliances, regardless of whether it a coffee maker or a high voltage transmission line, emit both electric and magnetic fields.
  • Most household appliances and electrical equipment are manufactured to tolerate a 10% plus/minus change in voltage even while in operation.


  • Electric Power Plant Design

    Internationally, appoximately 85% of electricity generating power plants are of a design where pressurized steam is the force (prime mover) that drives the fan blades of the turbines (referred to as steam turbines). The fossil fuels indicated above, or the nuclear reactor / geothermal as the heat source, is burned to heat water in a large, industrial boiler to produce the steam. The most common type of design is the Impulse Turbine in which high temperature, pressurized steam is concentrated through a fixed nozzle(s) directly at the rotor blades at the one end of the turbine. The other end of the turbine's shaft is connected to the generator. The generator must rotate at a constant synchronous speed to produce a current frequency (measured in Hertz / Hz) compatible with the electric power system. For instance, in the United States, the generator(s) must rotate at 3,000 revolutions per minute for 50 Hz systems, and at 3,600 revolutions per minute for 60 Hz systems.

    A combi-unit is generating plant where a gas turbine was added to the existing steam boiler in order to increase yield. The gas turbine can be used independently or in combination with the steam turbine, depending on the amount of power required. The gas turbine uses low-Nox burners, so that the plant uses fuel efficiently and complies with environmental requirements for emissions.

    The newer, typical coal-fired electricity generating power plant utilizes a Fluidized-bed Combustion (FBC) boiler to heat the steam used to drive the turbine rotor fans. In an FBC design the coal is first crushed and then mixed with limestone. The mixed coal and limestone aggregate is supported on rising current of air (fluidized) and is combustible at a low temperature. The limestone removes sulfur released during the combustion process.

    By applying steam and oxygen under pressure to coal, coal can be "gasified" (Coal Gasification) or separated into hydrogen, carbon monoxide and several other gases. This creates a fuel that can be burned like natural gas and reduces emmission of mercury, sulfur, nitrogen and particulates (no-gaseous material). However, it is expensive to construct goal gasification plants and it requires substantial amounts of energy to complete the process.

    In a hydroelectric plant located perpendicular across a river, the system starts by diverting the water using a non-impounding structure called the weir. From the weir, the water enters the desander, where water sediments settle to the bottom and upstream non-biodegradable trash are filtered out. From the desander, the water is then transported through steel pipes called conveyance lines, which are laid out to follow the landscape’s contour. Then, the water drops at an angle through a pressurized steel pipe known as the penstock. The penstock leads directly to the power plant which houses the turbine units and generators. The water from the penstock will impinge on the runner blades of the turbines causing a rotating motion, which turns the shaft attached to the generators. The generators are connected to a transformer substation where the energy produced is transmitted to the main grid for distribution. At the side of the power plant is the tailrace where the water that passed through the system is brought back to the river.

    U.S. Existing Capacity by Energy Source (2008)
    (Megawatts)
    Energy Source Number of Generators Generator Nameplate Capacity Net Summer Capacity Net Winter Capacity
    Coal 1,445 337,300 313,322 315,461
    Petroleum 3,768 63,655 57,445 61,538
    Natural Gas 5,467 454,611 397,432 427,703
    Other Gases 102 2,262 1,995 1,958
    Nuclear 104 106,147 100,755 102,494
    Hydroelectric Conventional 3,996 77,731 77,930 77,694
    Wind 494 24,980 24,651 24,698
    Solar Thermal and Photovoltaic 89 539 536 455
    Wood and Wood Derived Fuels 353 7,730 6,864 6,905
    Geothermal 228 3,281 2,256 2,409
    Other Biomass 1,412 4,854 4,186 4,263
    Pumped Storage 151 20,355 21,858 21,768
    Other 49 1,042 942 968
    Total 17,658 1,104,486 1,010,171 1,048,313

    Source:   www.eia.doe.gov/cneaf/electricity/epa/epat1p2.html  


    Power plants are are identified by how many Megawatts of electricity the plant can generate, which is the sum of the gross capacity of the number of generating units located within the plant.

  • The largest (in terms of generating capacity) power plant in the world is the Itaipu hydroelectric power plant along the Brazil and Paraguay border, capable of 14,750 MW.
  • The second largest plant in the world is the Three Gorges hydroelectric plant in China, capable of producing 12,070 MW.
  • The largest plant in the United States is the Grand Coulee facility (U S Bureau of Reclamation, WA), capable of 7,079 MW.
  • The largest coal-fired power plant in the United States is the Scherer Power Plant (Juliette, Georgia), capable of 880 MW.
  • The largest photovoltaic solar plant in the United States is the Alamosa, Colorado, SunEdison plant capable of 8.22 MW (the U.S. Air Force is construction a photovoltaic solar plant at Nellis Air Force Base that will generate 15 MW).
  • The largest amount of MWh generated by a single plant in the United States is the Palo Verde facility owned by Arizona Public Service Co., which generated 26,782,391 MWh (2007).
  • Generator capacity usage is not always 100% due to problems and / or scheduled maintenance and repair work. Every plant operator needs to maintain a reserve margin, which is the excess of generation capacity over peak demand, in order to be able to cope with an equipment breakdown or scheduled maintenance and repair. The international industry standard reserve margin is approximately 15.0%.

    Base load power plants are designed to operate 24-hours per day, generating electricity at an even, consistent level 7-days per week, year-round. The reason for this is that electric power cannot be stored, it can only be produced. In order for there to be sufficient power and any given time, peak and off peak, electricity must be continuosly generated and transmitted into the grid system constantly and consistently. These are normally coal-powered or nuclear-reactor powered generating facilities as they rely upon a stable-price fuel source.

    Some power plants may sit as a “spinning reserve” during off-peak or on-peak periods. Peaking plants (or sometimes referred to as "Peakers") are turned on or “dispatched” as demand increases above the normal base load demand. These facilities are essentially power plants that get switched on only a few times per year, usually only during the Summer months. Peaking plants are usually more expensive to operate, often fueled by refined petroleum products, or natural gas, and have a fuel cost per kWh higher than a baseload plant because the fuel is purchased on the spot market at the moment when the facility is started up. Some base load plants are large enough that they have additional generators available on standby to meet peak demand.

    Blackouts occur due to system failure. If one plant in the grid suddenly quits producing power (lightning strike, downed power line or mechanical failure), the other plants on the network must be able to increase their output to make up the difference. If the power plants are already working near their maximum output, then they will automatically shut down rather than exceed their maximum threshold. As plants shut down, they place the burden on remaining plants, which in turn must also shut down, leading to a shut down of the entire system.

    When the electricity goes off a modern metropolitan area, region or nation can go into paralysis.
  • Interior and exterior lighting goes off.
  • Air conditioning goes off.
  • If the present season is Winter then any furnace designed with an electric switch / electric spark switch will not function.
  • Traffic light systems will cease to operate.
  • Subway systems will cease to operate.
  • Airports usually have backup generator capabilities but priority will be given to landing aircraft, and takeoffs will be curtailed.
  • Hospitals usually have backup generator capabilities but priority will be given to maintaining the status quo and scheduled surgeries will be curtailed.
  • Some landline telephone systems have a separate power source over the telephone line. However, if the system is not designed that way, or the telephone is a handheld model that relys upon a transceiver base station then it will not operate.
  • Mobile telephone / cell phone systems will not operate.
  • Many radio stations and television stations have backup generator capabilities but most consumers may not be able to receive a broadcast.
  • Desktop computers at home and in the office will cease to function. Air conditioning used to cool off servers or server rooms will not be available and operations will have to be powered down if they are even on a backup generator.
  • Alarm systems will cease to function.
  • Both commercial and household food refrigeration goes off and the continuing length of the blackout can lead to substantial food loss.
  • The last major blackout in the United States was August 14, 2003, 4:09pm through 4:13pm EDT (final stage), when after several generator trips (shut down) earlier in the day, the 345 kV Harding-Chamberlin Transmission Line in northern Ohio tripped due to thermal sagging into the trees below, which tripped 2 other 345 kV lines (Hanna-Juniper and the Star-South Canton). When these lines disconnected, electricity began flowing over other transmission lines, including the underlying 138 kV systems, which began to overload. The result was the eventual shut down of the Eastern Interconnection electricity grid due to a cascading series of line disconnects when voltage and frequency began to substantially fluctuate.

    Brownouts occur due to a decline in an electric grid’s voltage for short periods of time. Brownouts are sometimes intentionally instituted during times of peak demand in order to prevent any one plant on the grid from approaching its maximum power supply threshold and shutting down, which might lead to a blackout. Rolling blackouts occur when an electrical system is unable to meet heavy peak demand because of a deficiency in the power supply. An emergency electricity purchase, voluntary curtailment, contracted curtailment and/or voltage reduction may alleviate the situation. A public Power Warning appeal may also be issued when an immediate reduction in power usage is necessary to avert overload of the electrical system. A Power Interruption Alert is issued to the public indicating that load shedding (instantaneous cutting of power to customers) or rolling blackouts are imminent. The temporarily disconnecting of electrical circuits on a rotating basis is an attempt to unilaterally reduce demand in order to avert the widespread crash of the regional grid.

    A power surge occurs when an electric grid voltage suddenly goes from the normal supply to 110% above normal supply.

    Electricity generation measurement:
     
    W / Watt
    kW / Kilowatt (1,000 watts)
    MW / Megawatt (1,000,000 watts or 1,000 kilowatts)
    GW / Gigawatt (1,000,000,000 watts or 1,000,000 kilowatts or 1,000 megawatts)
    TW / Terawatt (1,000,000,000,000 watts or 1,000,000,000 kilowatts or 1,000,000 megawatts or 1,000 gigawatts)
    kWh / Kilowatt hour
    MWh / Megawatt hour
    TWh / Terawatt hour

    The electricity generated by the plant is transported directly from the generator via a transformer system to the grid as every power station has a transformer station that connects to high-voltage lines. This is known as a step-up substation as the electricity voltage is stepped up to allow for more efficient long distance transmission.


    Power Plant Operation Credit Issues

  • Type of fuel (hydroelectric, natural gas, petroleum, coal, nuclear, solar, wind, biomass, landfill gas, waste) and the ability to switch between fuel sources.
  • Natural gas and pteroleum price volatility (coal as a fuel source is less of a price volatility issue) plus any collateral posting requirements related to fuel hedges.
  • Concentration on one or several large customers.
  • Competition with other power plant operators.
  • Generator downtime related to accident, maintenance or weather conditions results in a reduction of revenue.
  • Wholesale power price volatility.
  • Debt level related to plant construction.


  • Power Plant Fuels

    Please also see the separate page for the Coal Industry & Commodity Market and also see the separate page for the Natural Gas Industry & Commodity Market

    According to the U.S. department of Energy, Office of Electricity Delivery and Energy Reliability, in 1940, 10% of total energy consumption in the United States was used to produce electricity. In 1970, that amount had increased to 25%, and as of 2008 it is 40%.

    The cost to generate electricity fluctuates daily and monthly depending on the mix of fuel, and when it was purchased, used by the generating facility. Power plants attempt to enter into long-term supply contracts in order to stabilize operating expenses. Overall, the long-term trend has been that electricity prices are increasing because fuel costs have been increasing: Coal price has increased from a 1999 average of $1.22 per Million Btu to $2.07 in 2008; Distillate fuel (No. 2) has increased from a 1999 average of $4.03 per Million Btu to $20.08 in 2008; Natual gas has increased from a 1999 average of $2.57 per Million Btu to $9.11 in 2008.

  • Fossil fuels such as a coal, petroleum liquids and natural gas are also known as thermal fuels. In the United States, more than half of the electricity generated comes from coal (anthracite, bituminous coal, subbituminous coal, lignite, waste coal, coke and synthetic coal) fired plants while natural gas is the fastest growing fuel source for newly constructed electric power plants and planned construction of electric power generating plants. There are also plants that have a fuel switching capability, for instance switching between several types of petroleum liquids or switching between natural gas and petroleum liquids (and vice versa), which is primarily No. 2 fuel oil (diesel fuel).
  • Coal will continue to be the dominant fuel used for electric power production in the United States for the foreseeable future due to the low cost and abundance of coal supply within the continental United States. Historically, most base-load capacity has been provided using coal (or nuclear technologies) because, once the plants have been built, low fuel costs make them relatively cheap to operate continuously. However, the trade-off of environmental problems related to carbon emssions (carbon dioxide, sulfur dioxide and nitrogen oxides) is well documented. Secondly, the use of coal is not efficient: 64% of the heat energy created from burning coal (to heat steam) escapes through the smokestacks into the air.
  • Natural gas remains the dominant source of peak capacity because power plants using that fuel are less expensive to build than coal-fired plants or nuclear reactors and easier to start up and shut down.
  • After coal, natural gas and petroleum distillate fuels, the other major fuel source for electricity generation the is already in use today is nuclear energy.
  • Waste incineration is also a source of fuel in which electricity generation is actually a byproduct of the waste management process. Similarly, waste heat from industrial processes can also be utilized to produce electricity as a byproduct.
  • Renewable energy (natural forces) used in electricity generation include moving water (hydro), wind (wind-driven turbines), biomass fuels and solar power (either in the form of solar thermal energy as a heat source or in the form of the sun's rays striking photovoltaic cells to directly produce electricity).
  • The International Energy Agency (IEA) OECD Electricity Production by Fuel Type Report indicates that within the OECD:
  • For the nine months ending September 30, 2009, 7,333 TWh were generated.
  • Combustible Fuels as the fuel source accounted for 61% of electricity generation
  • Nuclear accounted for 22% of electricity production
  • Hydroelectric accounted for 14% of electricity generation
  • Geothermal / Wind / Solar / Other accounted for 3% of electricity production.
  • How to determine which fuel to utilize in electrical power generation? Each primary fuel source must be converted to a common physical unit, which in the United States is the British thermal unit (Btu). The Btu is a precise measure of the amount of energy required to raise the temperature of 1 pound of water 1 degree Fahrenheit.
     
  • 1 Gallon of No. 2 Diesel = 139,000 Btu
  • 1 Pound of Coal = 10,000 Btu
  • 1 Cubic Foot of Natural Gas = 1,021 Btu
  • 1 Kilowatt-hour of Electricity = 3,412 Btu; A kilowatt-hour is a unit of work or energy equal to that done by one kilowatt of power acting for one hour. A kilowatt is 1,000 watts or 1.34 horsepower.

  • 0.0245 Gallon of No. 2 Fuel Oil = 1 Kilowatt-hour of Electricity
  • 0.3412 Pound of Coal = 1 Kilowatt-hour of Electricity
  • 3.3418 Cubic Foot of Natural Gas = 1 Kilowatt-hour of Electricity
  • Average Price of No. 2 Fuel Oil Delivered to Electric Utility Plants in 2006: $1.982 per gallon
    Average Price of Coal Delivered to Electric Utility Plants in 2006: $34.26 per short ton (2,000 pounds) / $0.017 per pound
    Average Price of Natural Gas Delivered to Electric Utility Plants in 2006: $7.09 per Mcf (thousand cubic feet) / $0.0071 per foot

    Coal was the least expensive primary fuel source in 2006:
  • Cost of 1 Kilowatt-hour of Electricity (No. 2 Fuel Oil): $0.0487
  • Cost of 1 Kilowatt-hour of Electricity (Coal): $0.0058
  • Cost of 1 Kilowatt-hour of Electricity (Natural Gas): $0.0237
  • EIA average cost of fossil-fuel receipts at Electric Generating Plants (Nominal dollars per Million Btu, including taxes):

    YearCoalResidual Fuel OilDistillate Fuel OilPetroleum CokeNatural Gas
    2006$1.69$7.85$13.28$1.33$6.94
    2007$1.77$8.64$14.85$1.51$7.11
    2008$2.07$13.62$21.46$2.11$9.02
    2009$2.21$8.71$13.17$1.62$4.70

    Source:   www.eia.doe.gov/emeu/mer/pdf/pages/sec9_15.pdf   (.pdf format)

    Why has natural gas become the most popular fuel for new and repowered (rebuilt) electricity generating plants in the United States?
  • Burns "cleaner" than coal and pretroleum distallates.
  • The relationship between power output to fuel consumed to produce the power is good.
  • Proven supply with the United States is substantial thus supply disruption is low.
  • Delivery is through a pipeline, which has a one time construction cost and precludes the necessity of surface transport delivery (rail, truck).
  • Exhaust gas is easily vented.
  • A methane plant infrastructure can be quickly modified to burn hydrogen.


  • Environmental Issues

    The use of natural gas as a fuel source in combustion gas turbine generators is promoted as a less environmentally damaging fuel. However, with all fuels there are still problems:
  • Particulate matter emissions (PM and PM10) are formed from non-combustible ash and metals in the fuel, and trace inorganic matter drawn in by the inlet turbine air. Natural gas contains very low ash and metal content. However, secondary reactions caused by the introduction of ammonia (used to control NOx emissions) will generate fine particulate matter in the form of ammonium salts.
  • Sulfur dioxide (SO2) is formed in the turbine from the oxidation of sulfur in the fuel.
  • Carbon monoxide (CO) forms in turbines from incomplete combustion of fuel. Adequate fuel residence time and high temperature in the combustion zone can ensure minimal CO formation. However, the increase in temperature causes an exponential increase in NOx formation.
  • VOCs form in the turbine from incomplete combustion of the fuel. Adequate fuel residence time and high temperature can ensure minimal VOC formation.
  • Sources of nitrogen in the combustion process include atmospheric nitrogen and fuel bound nitrogen, commonly referred to as “thermal” and “fuel” NOx respectively. Due to the negligible amounts of nitrogen found in natural gas, emphasis on controlling NOx emissions from combustion turbines has been placed on reducing the formation of thermal NOx.
  • The burning of coal as a fuel source creates environmental problems. Scrubbers is a process where flue gas desulphurization removes 80% to 90% of sulfur dioxide (SO2) from power plant exhaust stacks.

    Bag houses are tightly woven cloth bags that are located in the flue and collect approxiamtely 90% of dust particles (fly ash) in the flue gas. Electrostatic precipitators are also used to collect ash particles for disposal.

    On Friday, February 8, 2008, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit ruled (No. 05-1097; State of New Jersey, et al., versus the Environmental Protection Agency, and the Utility Air Regulatory Group) that the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) violated Section 112 of the federal Clean Air Act (CAA) when it imposed a Delisting Rule, delisting coal- and oil-fired Electric Utility Steam Generating Units (EGUs) from established regulatory guidelines for mercury emission related to plant operations (coal naturally contains mercury in trace quantities, a portion of which is released during combustion for energy or heat generation).
    pacer.cadc.uscourts.gov/docs/common/opinions/200802/05-1097a.pdf   (.pdf format)

    Within the European Union, generating plants are being requested to convert from coal to natural gas as the fuel source in order to be compliant with EU carbon directives. However, there is the issue of fuel security as most of the EU's natural gas supply comes from Russia.

    For Carbon Trading / Carbon Offset & Renewable Energy Credits, please see the separate Carbon Trading Page.



    FutureGen

    FutureGen is the plan by a public-private partnership to construct a coal-fired electricity generating power plant with the capability to capture carbon dioxide emissions and then store it underground. In January 2008, the U.S Department of Energy publicly indicated that it would no longer be involved in the project. The DOE had indicated that the program’s budget had increased to $1.8 billion, approximately double the original estimate for the project thus it could no longer support it (the DOE had originally committed to funding 74% of the project's development costs in 2003). The DOE's partners in the project, the FutureGen Alliance, Inc., which is a consortium of coal companies and electric utilities, publicly indicated that it disagreed with the DOE's position. The Alliance believes that costs have increased due to inflation related to the market increase for the cost of materials (steel, concrete and power plant components) due to the volume of costruction in the world thus the DOE's commitment is still the same proportion adjusted for inflation. Alliance members include American Electric Power, Anglo American, BHP Billiton, the China Huaneng Group, CONSOL Energy Inc., E.ON U.S., Foundation Coal, Luminant, PPL Corporation, Rio Tinto Energy America, Peabody Energy, Southern Company, and Xstrata Coal.
    www.futuregenalliance.org/

    FutureGen utilizes a technology referred to as CCS (Carbon Capture and Storage) to produce hydrogen to power the electricity generating turbines and then pumps the carbon dioxide underground, under pressure (referred to a carbon dioxide sequestering) into saline aquifiers thus the prototype plant would produce "zero" emissions. The key to the success of such a program would be the ability to perform the gasification of coal and the sequestering of the carbon impurities on a large enough scale to make a difference (tens of billions of tons would have to be pumped on an annual basis in order for the procedure to have any effect on reducing emissions).



    U.S. Electricity Generating Industry (Ownership / Producer Type)

    Utility operated electricity generating plants in the United States are categorized by ownership structure:
  • Private companies, also known as Investor Owned Utilities (IOU), who operate the facilities for profit and whose stock is publicly traded.
  • Publicly-owned utility, owned by a state or municipal government agency, and were established to provide service to their communities and nearby consumers at cost, returning excess funds to consumers in the form of community contributions, increased economies and efficiencies in operations, and reduced rates.
  • Cooperatives, which are owned by cooperative members and / or the consumers, and were established to provide electricity to those members. These electric utilities operate in rural areas with low concentrations of consumers because these areas historically have been viewed as uneconomical operations for investor-owned utilities.
  • Federal electric utilities in the United States are part of several agencies in the U.S. Government:
  • Army Corps of Engineers in the Department of Defense
  • Bureau of Indian Affairs and the Bureau of Reclamation in the Department of the Interior
  • International Boundary and Water Commission in the Department of State
  • Power Marketing Administrations in the Department of Energy (Bonneville, Southeastern, Southwestern, and Western Area)
  • Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA)
  • Publicly-owned electric utilities also include the Electric Authority, which is usually a nonprofit corporation established as a joint action agency to generate and provide wholesale power to municipally-owned electric systems (public utility / distributors, who also own and operate local substations and transmission lines). Similarly, there is also the State Power Authority, which is usually a state-owned, non-profit, public-benefit power organization that owns and operates generating facilities and high voltage transmission lines, and provides lowest-cost electricity within the state to distributors and cooperatives.

    Non-utility operated electricity generating facilities sell electricity to utilities, wholesalers and commercial buyers both under long-term contracts and on exchanges (wholesale short-term contracts or daily spot market). There are several categories of non-utility electricity generating facility in the United States:
  • A Qualifying Facility (QF) established under the Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act of 1978 (PURPA) consist of 2 categories: qualifying small power production facilities and qualifying cogeneration facilities. A small power production facility is a generating facility of 80 MW or less whose primary energy source is renewable (hydro, wind or solar), biomass, waste, or geothermal resources. A cogeneration facility is a generating facility that sequentially produces electricity and another form of useful thermal energy (such as heat or steam) in a way that is more efficient than the separate production of both forms of energy (the electrical, thermal, chemical and mechanical output of the cogeneration facility is used fundamentally for industrial, commercial, residential or institutional purposes and is not intended fundamentally for sale to an electric utility).
  • Independent power producers that produce and sell electricity on the wholesale market at market-based rates, and do not have franchised service territories. Most are designated as exempt wholesale generators, which relieves them of many of the regulatory requirements applicable to traditional utilities subject to FERC regulation.
  • Other combined heat and power plants that are often co-located at nearby industrial sites. These facilities may be classified as commercial or industrial depending on the NAICS code associated with the co-located industry.
  • Existing Capacity by Producer Type (2008)
    (Megawatts)
    Producer Type Number of Generators Generator Nameplate Capacity Net Summer Capacity Net Winter Capacity
    Electric Power Sector
    Electric Utilities 9,371 632,923 584,908 603,610
    Independent Power Producers 5,344 395,594 359,044 373,888
    Total 14,715 1,028,517 943,951 977,497
    Combined Heat and Power Sector
    Electric Power 654 42,937 37,309 40,274
    Commercial 639 2,593 2,312 2,407
    Industrial 1,650 30,439 26,599 28,134
    Total 2,943 75,969 66,219 70,815
    Total All Sectors 17,658 1,104,486 1,010,171 1,048,313
    Source: www.eia.doe.gov/cneaf/electricity/epa/epat1p3.html

    The generation segment of the electric power industry is the whoelsale market, and this is where competition was promoted in the U.S. through deregulation. The profit motive is supposed to be responsible for making electric power generating facilities as efficient as possible, hence lower wholesale electricity prices. Secondly, private ownership is supposed to shift the operating financial risks away from the utilities’ ratepayers and to the shareholders. Conversely, the shareholders receive a steady dividend payment stream. Market pricing is also supposed to clearly indicate to generating facilities which market or region has sufficient capacity and which market or region may require additional capacity investment.

    Companies that construct electric power plants typically expect the plant to operate for 30 to 50 years. Electricity can be sold by the generating facility owners into the markets administered by the regional ISOs / RTOs (see below), directly to a utility or to an energy service company (ESCO; see below), which are both Load Serving Entities (LSEs). If the plant is designed as base load generating facility then the owners tend to seek a long-term fuel supply contract and a long-term, bilateral power sales contract with another utility, wholesalers and commercial buyers, or distributor (retail delivery).






    Non-U.S. Electricity Generating Industry




    Byproducts

    The use of coal as a fuel source to power generators often results in the creation of ash and slag byproduct, both which have commercial value and can be sold to increase the revenues earned by the power plant.



      Transmission & Power Grids
     

    United States

    In the United States and in many other nations, electric power is transmited and distributed over an electro-mechanical grid system. The grid system consists of electricity production plants, sub stations, transformers and thousands of miles of high voltage electric transmission lines.

  • As the electricity leaves the generating plant is passes through a transformer that steps up the voltage for transmission (high voltage or 69,000 volts or higher, to as high as 750,000 volts).
  • Once the voltage is stepped up the electricity can be transmitted for miles along the transmission lines. However, approximately 10% of electricity transmitted over high voltage lines leaches out and is lost.
  • Once the electricity reaches a point of distribution a second transformer the steps down the voltage for local distribution lines (115,000 volts or 69,000 volts).
  • Local transformer (located on poles or buried in residential neighborhoods) step down the voltage a final time (12,470 volts) before the eletrical current enters a household. In addition, Single-phase power (sine waves cross 0 volts at 120 times per second) is primarily used in residential distribution. Transformers include single-phase and three-phase overhead transformers, single-phase and three-phase pad-mounted transformers, single-phase and three-phase substation transformers, single-phase overhead and pad-mounted step voltage regulators, single-phase auto-boosters.
  • Transmission line capacity for bulk power transmission is measured in kilovolts (kV). Transmission line capacity varies from 345 kV to 499 kV, 500 kV to 699 kV, 700 kV to 799 kV, 1,000 kV (DC). Large new lines (in excess of 100 miles) have a capacity of 765 kV and require less right-of-way compared to several of the smaller 345 kV lines. According to the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Electricity Delivery and Energy Reliability, the United States operates approximately 157,810 miles of high voltage (voltage greater than 230kV; 98% AC lines / 2% DC lines) electric transmission lines.

        Typical Electric Transmission / Distribution Lines; Source: OSHA
                                                    Source: OSHA

    Transmission does not mean that a clearly identifiable and quantifiable amount of electricity (MW / Megawatts) is generated at a power plant and sent a quantifiable distance directly through power lines to a specific utility / distributor, and that specific electricity is used solely by the utility's customers. What transmission really means is that the power generating facility generates and transmits a specific amount of electicity for a specific length of time into one part of the grid, a pool of electricity exists, and a utility withdraws a specific amount of electricity for a specific length of time from another part of the grid. The supply of electricity coming into the grid (generation) and the demand for electricity at any given time (load) must be balanced (load balance) at all times because a substantial imbalance would result in the collapse of the grid (blackout).

    However, there can be congestion (delivery problems or constraints) in the electricity transmission grid because transmission lines may not have enough capacity (thermal limits on lines or voltage limits on buses) to carry all the electricity generated and/or required to meet the demand at a specific location. Thus, a series of separate transmission line interconnections may be necessary for a utility / distributor to access all of the electricity it requires to meet is base and peak loads. In addition, transmission of power over wires encounters resistance, the measure of how easily electrical current flows through a substance, and resistance creates losses in the system.


    Interconnections

    The United States is first divided into three large grids which are overseen by the North American Reliability Corporation (NERC), which maintains the regional reliability and security standards approved by the U.S. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC):

    Interconnections; source: Bouchecl
     
  • Eastern Interconnection: supplies power east of the Rocky Mountains
  • Western Interconnection: supplies power west of the Rocky Mountains and into Alberta and British Columbia
  • Texas Interconnection: supplies the State of Texas
  • The 2 large eastern and western grids arose because the electricity transmission system originally developed from the population centers on the coasts and then spread inland into the midsection of the country. Each of these 3 continental grids are electrically isolated (function on different frequencies) so that a problem in one grid will not spread to another.

    The Eastern Interconnection encompasses the entire eastern, southern and central United States and eastern Canada. The territory includes includes the states of North Dakota, South Dakota, Nebraska, Kansas, Oklahoma, a small portion of Texas (and all states to the east) as well as Saskatchewan and Canadian provinces to the east. This territory also includes the NERC reliability regions within FRCC, MRO, NECC, RFC, SERC and SPP (see below).

    The Western Interconnection encompasses the the states of Washington, Oregon, California, Idaho, Nevada, Utah, Arizona, Colorado, Wyoming, portions of Montana, South Dakota, New Mexico and a portion of Texas, the Canadian provinces of British Columbia and Alberta in Canada, and a portion of CFE's system in Baja California in Mexico. This territory also includes the NERC reliability region within WECC (see below).

    The Texas Interconnection encompasses a large geographic area of the State of Texas and ERCOT (see below).

    As indicated above, each of the 3 continental grids function on different frequencies (all approximately 60 Hz) in order to isolate any potential widespread problems. Electricity transfer between any two of the Interconnections, which does happen commercially, can only be accomplished through special alternating current/direct current/alternating current (AC/DC/AC) tie converter stations. These converter station ties include the Miles City Tie in Montana, the Rapid City Tie in Western South Dakota, the McNeill Tie in Western Saskatchewan, Canada, the Blackwater Tie and the Artesia Tie, both in Eastern New Mexico, the Stegall Tie located southwest of Scottsbluff, Nebraska, and the Sidney Tie (also referred to as the Virginia Smith converter station) located just north of Sidney, Nebraska.

    The Tres Amigas project is a proposal to utilize superconductor electricity pipelines to link the 3 continental interconnections near Clovis, NM. The pipleines are really direct current (DC) superconductor power cables powered by AMSC high temperature superconductor (HTS) wire and high-powered voltage-source AC/DC power converters (built by American Superconductor Corp., who has already installed one of the cables for National Grid on Long Island, NY). Tres Amigas will also function as a power market hub, enabling the buying and selling of electricity between the nation’s three Interconnections, which does not exist today, and will also allow for the transmission of electricity form renewable source to be transferred between regions.

    The U.S. grid also interconnects with Canada: Ontario Independent Electricity System Operator (IESO), Alberta Electric System Operator (AESO), Hydro Quebec.

    The U.S. grid also interconnects with Mexico through transmission facilities of San Diego Gas & Electric Company (SDG&E), El Paso Electric Company (EPE), Central Power and Light Company (CPL), and the Comision Federal de Electricidad (CFE), the national electric utility of Mexico.


    Reliability Councils

    Within the 3 continental grids there are eight regional electric reliability councils under NERC's authority:

    Regional Electric Reliability Councils; source: Bouchecl
     
  • Florida Reliability Coordinating Council (FRCC)
  •  
  • Midwest Reliability Organization (MRO)
  •  
  • Northeast Power Coordinating Council (NPCC)
  •  
  • ReliabilityFirst Corporation (RFC)
  •  
  • Southeastern Reliability Corporation (SERC)
  •  
  • Southwest Power Pool, Inc. (SPP)
  •  
  • Texas Regional Entity (TRE) (ERCOT Interconnection)
  •  
  • Western Electricity Coordinating Council (WECC) (Western Interconnection)

  •             Source: Bouchecl


    Balancing authorities within each council are responsible for managing the minute-to-minute supply/demand balance for electricity within their borders to assure reliability. Each one of the regional electric reliability councils maintain an Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT), which is the fixed cost to transmit power within the respective system.

    The Midwest Reliability Organization (MRO) was formed on January 1, 2005, as the successor to the Mid-continent Area Power Pool (MAPP). The council's territory includes all or part of the states of Minnesota, North Dakota, Nebraska, Montana, South Dakota, Iowa, Wisconsin, the Upper Peninsula of Michigan, and the Canadian provinces of Saskatchewan and Manitoba. Within the MRO are 4 DC ties between the Eastern interconnection to the Western Interconnection.

    The Northeast Power Coordinating Council (NPCC) was formed January 19, 1966, as the successor to the Canada-United States Eastern Interconnection (CANUSE). The council's territory includes all of the states of Maine, Vermont, New Hampshire, Massachusetts, New York, Connecticut, Rhode Island, and the Canadian provinces of Ontario, Québec, New Brunswick, Nova Scotia and Prince Edward Island.

    The ReliabilityFirst Corporation (RFC) was formed on January 1, 2006 from the merger of ECAR, MAAC, and MAIN. Some MAIN members joined ReliabilityFirst, others joined Midwest Reliability Organization (MRO) and the Southeastern Electric Reliability Council, Inc. (SERC). The council's territory includes all of the states of Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware, Maryland, West Virginia, Ohio, Indiana, and portions of the states of Wisconsin, Michigan, Illinois, Kentucky and Virginia.

    The Southeast Electric Reliability Corporation (SERC) was formed on April 29, 2005. The council's territory includes all or part of the states of Missouri, Alabama, Tennessee, North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia, Mississippi, and portions of Iowa, Illinois, Kentucky, Virginia, Oklahoma, Arkansas, Louisiana, Texas and Florida. SERC’s current subregions are Central (formerly the TVA Subregion), Delta (formerly the Entergy Subregion), Gateway (in 2006, SERC membership expanded to include several members in the central part of the country), Southeastern (formerly Southern Subregion) and VACAR (Virginia - Carolinas Reliability Agreement).

    The Southwest Power Pool, Inc. (SPP) was formed in 1941, incorporated in 1994, and was granted RTO status in 2004. The council's territory includes all of the states of Kansas and Oklahoma, and parts of the states of Nebraska, Missouri, Arknasas, New Mexico, Texas, and Louisiana. Within the SPP are both of the DC ties to the ERCOT Texas Interconnection and several of the DC ties between the Western Interconnection and the Eastern Interconnection.

    The Western Electricity Coordinating Council (WECC) was formed on April 18, 2002, from the merger of the Western Systems Coordinating Council (WSCC), the Southwest Regional Transmission Association (SWRTA), and the Western Regional Transmission Association (WRTA).




    Regional Transmission Organizations (RTO) / Independent System Operators (ISO)

    In addition to the reliability councils, several Regional Transmission Organizations (RTO) / Independent System Operators (ISO) direct electricity across the transmission grid in certain regions. The ISOs / RTOs do not own the transmission lines and infrastructure. Rather, the ISOs / RTOs operate as an independent administrator for the oversight of electricity transmission traffic and scheduling so that all participants have open access and are served equally, and system integrity is maintained (private / public companies own the towers, wires and substations but there is no competition in relation to transmission service provided to wholesale customers within any interconnection). These RTO / ISO organizations also administer their respective region’s wholesale electricity markets (see below). ISO / RTO Map; source: FERC
     
  • California ISO (CASIO)
  •  
  • Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT ISO)
  •  
  • ISO New England (ISO-NE)
  •  
  • Midwest ISO (MISO ISO)
  •  
  • Mid-Continent Area Power Pool (MAPP)
  •  
  • New York ISO (NYISO)
  •  
  • PJM Interconnection (PJM)
  •  
  • Southwest Power Pool, Inc. (SPP)
  • There can be several hundred power plants within a ISO system who are scheduled to provide power on any given day. The ISO / RTO are supposed to provide non-discriminatory transmission access within the continental United States. An ISO manages its respective system by notifying (dispatches) each plant in order, starting with the power plant that submitted the lowest supply offer. Simultaneously, the ISO schedules the delivery of electricity through the high-voltage transmission lines. An ISO is only concerned with the participants and voltage level within its immediate system (there are interconnections between each participant in a regional ISO, and there are also continental bulk power connections between ISOs). The ISO / RTO also constantly checks its respective system to determine whether there is sufficient power avaliable for the hourly forecast of electricity consumption (load balance).

    The Califronia ISO (CAISO) encompasses most of Califronia and a portion of Baja California (Mexico) and is divided into 3 zones: NP-15, ZP-26, SP-15.

    The Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT) is divided into 4 regions: North, South, West and Houston.

    The Midwest ISO (MISO) encompasses all or most of the states of North Dakota, South Dakota, Nebraska, Minnesota, Iowa, Wisconsin, Illinois, Indiana, Michigan and parts of Montana, Missouri, Kentucky, and Ohio. Hubs include Cinergy, First Energy, Illinois, Michigan, Minnesota.

    The New England ISO (NE-ISO) encompasses the states of Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Rhode Island and Vermont. Massachusetts is also divided into Northeastern Massachusetts/Boston (NEMA), Southeastern Massachusetts (SEMA) and Western/Central Massachusetts (WCMA).

    The New York ISO (NYISO) is confined within the State of New York and is divided into 11 zones: Capital (Zone F), Central (Zone C), Dunwoodie (Zone I), Genesee (Zone B), Hudson Valley (Zone G), Long Island (Zone K), Millwood (Zone H), Mohawk Valley (Zone E), New York City (Zone J), North (Zone D), West (Zone A).

    The PJM Interconnection (PJM) encompasses all or most of the states of Delaware, Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Maryland, New Jersey, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Virginia, West Virginia and the District of Columbia. PJM is divided into 3 zones: PJM West Region, the PJM South Region / VACAR Control Zone, and the MAAC Control Zone. The PJM West Region is the aggregate of the Zones of Allegheny Power; Commonwealth Edison Company (including Commonwealth Edison Co. of Indiana); AEP East Operating Companies; The Dayton Power and Light Company; and the Duquesne Light Company. The VACAR Control Zone is the transmission facilities of Virginia Electric and Power Company. The MAAC Control Zone is the aggregate of the zones of Atlantic City Electric Company, Baltimore Gas and Electric Company, Delmarva Power and Light Company, Jersey Central Power and Light Company, Metropolitan Edison Company, PECO Energy Company, Pennsylvania Electric Company, Pennsylvania Power & Light Group, Potomac Electric Power Company, Public Service Electric and Gas Company and Rockland Electric Company.




    Power Marketing Administrations

    In addition to the reliability councils, the ISOs / RTOs, there are also 4 power marketing administrations within the U.S. Department of energy (DOE):Power Marketing Administrations Map; source: WAPA
     
  • Bonneville Power Administration (BPA)
  •  
  • Western Area Power Administration (WAPA)
  •  
  • Southwestern Power Administration (SWPA)
  •  
  • Southeastern Power Administration (SEPA)
  • The purpose of the power marketing administrations is to provide low-cost electricity (and related services including transmission) generated by hydroelectric power plants constructed wwihtin their respective regions. The wholesale power customers of these entities include cities and towns, rural electric cooperatives, public utility and irrigation districts, Federal and state agencies, investor-owned utilities, power marketers and Native American tribes.

    In the United States, the combined grid system has become unreliable in in supplying electric power due to several factors such as aging equipment, the presence of transmission bottlenecks, the effects of deregulation and regulatory change, and jurisdictional issues associated with the numerous stakeholders who control, regulate or impact parts of the grid (approximately 200,000 miles of power lines is owned by several hundred entities). In recent years, these factors have combined to discourage private sector investment in upgrading the nation's grid and in developing new transmission and distribution-related technologies. During 2003 / 2004, the 3 main grids began to have sensors installed under the Phasor Project, which will allow monitoring offices to rapidly pinpoint problems and isolate problems so that there is no repeat of a system-wide shutdown similar to which occurred in August 2004. The maintenence of electricity generation and transmission is substantial as every year there is the need for the replacement / addition of turbines, rehabilitatation or construction of distribution substations, rehabilitattion of the transmission network(s), and installation and restoration of generators.

    In the United States there are several transmission points for the delivery and trading of electric power:
  • CINER (Cinergy system, comprising the old systems of Public Service of Indiana and Cincinnati Gas & Electric Co.)
  • PJMW (Pennsylvania-New Jersey-Maryland pool, western hub)
  • ENTGY (Entergy system)
  • COMED (Commonwealth Edison system)
  • ERCOT (Electric Reliability Council of Texas
  • ECAR (East Central Area Reliability Council)
  • NEPOOL (New England power pool)
  • Palo Verde
  • Mid-Columbia - Mid-Columbia (Mid-C) is a general reference to 118 miles of the Columbia River in Central Washington where five hydro projects are located. These projects are owned and operated by Chelan County PUD, Grant County PUD and Douglas County PUD.
  • There are also several private companies in the United States that provide long-distance transmission services. U.S. companies with the largest transmssion capacity include:
  • AEP
  • Southern Company (27,000 miles of transmission lines, 3,400 substations, and more than 300,000 acres of right of way)
  • Duke Energy
  • Pacific Gas & Electric
  • MidAmerican
  • Xcel Energy
  • Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA)
  • Oncor (13,000 miles of electrical transmission lines and some 91,000 miles of distribution lines)
  • In the United States, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) regulates interstate transmission service provided by transmission-owning public utilities.

    As part of the proposed construction and increase of renewable energy resources (solar and wind), the U.S. would also need to construct additional transmission capacity to move power generated in rural area locations to the existing power grid or to metropolitan areas. The new grid infrastructure would also need to be designed to handle the fluctuating power level associated with solar and wind generation. In addition to the cost of the project is the related right-of-way access requirement in order to construct new transmission lines. In April 2009, the FERC approved transmission infrastructure investment rate incentives for a proposed 3,000-mile / 765 kV transmission network designed to deliver wind-powered renewable energy from North Dakota, South Dakota, Minnesota and Iowa to consumers in and around Chicago, Minneapolis and southeastern Wisconsin.



    OASIS

    In the United States, Open Access Same-Time Information System (OASIS) is an interactive website for transmitting utility information to customers in accordance with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's Rule 889 (1996; requires all IOUs to participate in and OASIS). These websites allow participants to post bids or offers for energy and see information regarding system demand forecasts, transmission outage / capacity status, and market prices.




    Europe

    In Europe, these entities are sometimes referred to as a Transmission System Operator (TSO). The European Network of Transmission System Operators for Electricity (ENTSO-E) is the single coordination agency for the TSOs (there were originally 6 predecessor associations: ATSOI, BALTSO, ETSO, NORDEL, UCTE and UKTSOA) as Europe has effectively been operating as a single interconnected system since 2007. There are still separate, direct current (DC) lines between several regions because power flows on them can be more easily controlled than AC lines but still allow power transfer to occur between regions.



    Australia

    In Australia, the AEMO (Australian Energy Market Operator) operates the the National Electricity Market (NEM). The NEM operates the Australian interconnected power system that runs for more than 5,000 kilometres from Port Douglas in Queensland to Port Lincoln in South Australia. The NEM interconnects five regional market jurisdictions including Queensland, New South Wales, Victoria, South Australia and Tasmania.








      Distribution
     

    Distribution is providing electrical power to local communities and individual customers, which is performed by the local electric company / utility who may also have electricity generating capabilities. Electricity is transmitted from power generating stations for miles along the transmission lines. Once the electricity reaches a point of distribution a transformer the steps down the voltage for local distribution lines. A local transformer (located on poles or buried in residential neighborhoods) steps down the voltage a final time (115KV) before the eletrical current enters a household. the connection to each individual residential and commercial consumer is metered to record actual usage. The local distributor may also have available secondary voltages such as 120/240 V 1 phase, 120/240 V 3 phase, and 120/208 V 3 phase. In older sections of the nation, electrical distribution lines are located above ground and elevated on poles. In newer residential construction areas in the United States, electrical distribution lines are buried. However, burying distribution lines cost more and it is more difficult to inspect and maintain buried lines.

    Local distributors are either private investor-owned utitlities (IOU), not-for-profit municipally-owned electric systems (public utility / service provider / electric cooperative, who may also own and operate generation facilities, local substations and transmission lines), and who may purchase power from a local Electric Authority, which is usually a nonprofit corporation established as a joint action agency to generate and provide wholesale power to the municipality or group of municipalities (utilities that do not own power plants are customers of the wholesale electricity market). Utilities are regulated by local, State, and Federal authorities, and in the case of many electric cooperatives, by their Board of Directors.

    According to the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Electricity Delivery and Energy Reliability, there are more than 3,100 electric utilities operating in the United States:
  • 213 stockholder-owned utilities (IOU) provide power to about 73% of customers.
  • 2,000 public utilities run by state and local government agencies provide power to about 15% of customers.
  • 930 electric cooperatives provide power to about 12% of customers.
  • In states that have been deregulated, which is California, Connecticut, Delaware, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island and Texas, consumers have the option to select the company that will provide electricity to a residential or commercial property. These companies, known as retail power marketers, Energy Supply Companies (ESCOs), Retail Energy Marketers (REMs), Retail Energy Suppliers (RES), and Retail Energy Providers (REPs) buy and sell electricity, but usually do not own or operate generation, transmission, or distribution facilities. These companies usually must apply for a Competitive Supplier and Electricity Broker License in the state that they operate. A company that is licensed as a Load Serving Entity (LSE) in a deregulated state is authorized to purchase power in the wholesale markets for large customers and deliver it to their retail meters. The purpose of the Retail Marketers existence is to offer a selection of electricity suppliers to the individual consumer. Thus, if one retailer negotiates a better supply contract with a power generating company than another retailer then the end-user / consumer has the opportunity to purchase their electricity from the retailer with the more advantageous pricing. In many deregulated states, monthly utility billing has been divided into two charges, delivery services and supplier services, in order for customers to select an electricity supplier and see the actual per kWh cost of the power only.

    Aggregation is a process by which several communities (or any group of retail customers) combine their residents into a single large buying group, which then attempts to negotiate a favorable kWh rate from a generator, wholesale marketer, retail marketer or existing utility. However, residents within the municipalities must be offered an opt-out option if they want to remain with their existing service.

    One of the key operating issues related to distribution is reliability. There are several key industry reliability measurements that determine how well the distributor is performing:
  • System Average Interruption Duration Index (SAIDI) measures the average duration of interruptions for the average customer and is calculated by taking the sum of all customer interruption durations (in minutes) and dividing it by the total number of customers served.
  • Customer Average Interruption Duration Index (CAIDI) measures the average repair time required to restore service experienced by the average customer who experiences an interruption.
  • System Average Interruption Frequency Index (SAIFI) measures the average frequency of interruptions for the average customer is calculated by taking the total number of customer interruptions and dividing it by the total number of customers served.
  • Momentary Average Interruption Event Frequency Index (MAIFIe) measures the average momentary interruption events (interruptions that last less than one minute) per average customer and is calculated by taking the total number of customer momentary interruption events and dividing it by the number of customers served.
  • L-Bar measures the average length of a service interruption / service outage and is calculated by taking the total sum of minutes of interuption and dividing by the total number of sustained interruptions in excess of one minute in length.
  • Most residential properties in the United States have two incoming voltage lines: 120 volts for lighting and appliance circuits and 240 volts for larger air conditioning and electric dryer circuits. Electricity only flows when a switch is placed in an "ON" position and a circuit is completed. Most lighting and wall socket circuits in a residential property are 15 amp circuits, while most electric dryers and air conditioners require larger 30 amp circuits.

    An electric meter registers the number of kilowatt hours used by a residential or commercial customer. There are two kinds of electric meters: the older dial meter and the newer digital meter. The digital meter is similar to the mileage odometer in an automobile: every time the number increases another kilowatt hour of electricity has been consumed.


    Electric Company / Utility Operation Credit Issues

  • Competition with other utility operators.
  • Wholesale power price volatility.
  • Debt level related to plant construction.
  • Customer payments come from through several channels / platforms (ACH, check, cash, mobile, telephone, web, mail and walk-in) and can be expensive and time consuming to process, record and archive.
  • Ability to reduce consumption by influencing when and how customers use electricity, for instance the introduction of conservation programs and incentives for switching electricity use from mid-day to evening. This also referred to as Demand-side Management, which are utility-sponsored activities designed to encourage consumers to modify patterns of electricity usage, including the timing and level of electricity demand.

  • Smart Grid

    The most recent development in the Transmission / Distribution segment is the proposal of the Smart Grid, which esentially means

  • adding a real-time sensor (for voltage and current monitoring)
  • advanced metering that captures electricity consumption data in real time
  • communication ability to the existing electrical grid and the two-way information flow between the generator, distributor and consumer
  • installation of smart / network connected home appliances and thermostats that can be remotely accessed

  • In the United States, the Smart Grid as national policy objective was first proposed in the Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007 and in February 2009, the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act specifically allocated $4.5 billion for Smart Grid implementation. The object of the Smart Grid is to conserve energy though better control at the distribution level (cope with power interruption form scheduled generators or an increase in supply from intermittant wind and solar generators) and at the point of consumption level (reduce usage or move usage to non-peak time).

    The first problem, and the major credit analysis issue, is who should / will pay for the installation of Smart Grid hardware and software?

  • If it is up to the utilities then will they have to increase rates in order to cover the cost of the hardware and installation?
  • If the installation of the hardware and software actually reduces electricity consumption then how will utilities continue to prosper, especially if they continue to be required to also subsidize renewable energy / distributed generation projects?
  • A second important, and related issue, is interoperability of the hardware and software. Which standards should be utilized and will there be any unforseen problems that may render an investment useless or impacted?

    Another issue related to the application of network information systems to the electrical grid is the issue of security. Electrical systems can be remotely accessed by computer over the Internet, which means that unauthorized persons can access and compromise the control of the system in order to purposefully disrupt electrical power transmission (not just the United States but any nation). In the United States, the integrity of any Smart Grid network is covered under the Federal Cybersecurity Act.

    Another issue related to the implementation of Smart Grid infrastructure is that of privacy: will information (power usage / consumption, appliances, etc.) be stored and if so, how will it be stored and who will have access to it? Will it be provided to marketers?

    Initial projects in the United States include:

  • Xcel Energy's SmartGridCity system in Boulder, CO, which will include 50,000 residential customers
  • Pecan Street Project sponsored by the Environmental Defense Fund in Austin, TX, which combines Smart Grid infrastructure with renewable energy projects.
  • Plan-it Wise Energy Program, which originated as a study by Connecticut Light & Power that clearly demonstrated that 3,000 smart metered customers reduced electricity consumption substantially, and led to the recommendation that all 1.2 million customers install smart meters.



    Utility / Distributor / Retailer / ESCO











      Regulation
     

    United States

    The U.S. Department of Energy forecasts that U.S. electricity consumption will grow by more than 30% over the next two decades (while the use of natural gas to produce electricity will increase by nearly 60%). For the majority of the twentieth century, the electric power industry in the United States was dominated by regulated monopoly utilities. The United states has been deregulating the electricity market and shifting away from vertically-integrated, publicly-owned utilities to privatizing segments of the industry. In the past 3 decades, the U.S. Congress has passed legislation to promote competition in wholesale electric power markets by either lowering entry barriers, increasing transmission access, or both. The purpose of the deregulation was to create a more efficient use of of capital and infrastructure, encourage expansion of capacity and the delivery of less expensive energy to end users. One of the most important developments was "unbundling", or the separation of transmission, generation, distribution, and marketing activities.

    In the United States, 24 states plus the District of Columbia originally enacted enabling legislation or issued a regulatory order to implement retail access to their respective electricity markets. The states that have been deregulated include Arizona, Arkansas, California, Connecticut, Delaware, Districit of Columbia, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Montana, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Texas, Virginia and West Virginia. In the retail / consumer market in these states, deregulation has meant that consumers have been given the opportunity to purchase electric power from competing electricity suppliers, which is supposed to result in lower prices. The states of Arizona, Arkansas, California, Montana, Nevada, New Mexico, Oregon, and Virginia essentially repealed or delayed deregulation after having initially approved legislation and then experienced problems or reviewed the problems incurred by other states.

    Status of Electricity Restructuring by U.S. State (Energy Information Administration):
    www.eia.doe.gov/cneaf/electricity/page/restructuring/restructure_elect.html

    Deregulation in the United States really means that:
  • Companies other than utilities can generate and sell electricity in the wholesale market.
  • Consumers can select their electricity supplier/provider/distributor in the retail market.
  • Transmission of electricity from power plants to utilities/distributors is still regulated.
  • Not every state in the U.S. has approved deregulation.
  • In the United States, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) is responsible for the approval of rates for wholesale sales of electricity and transmission in interstate commerce for jurisdictional utilities, power marketers, power pools, power exchanges and independent system operators.

    Overall, regulation of public power systems varies from state to state within the United States. In some States, the public utility commission exercises jurisdiction in whole or part over operations and rates of publicly owned systems. In most States, public power systems are regulated by local governments or are self-regulated. Municipal systems are usually governed by the local city council or an independent board elected by voters or appointed by city officials. Other public power systems are operated by public utility districts, irrigation districts, or special State authorities. Please see the List of State Public Service Commissions below.

    Generation operations are usually subject to regulation by the local state public utility commission (PUC), Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC), the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC), the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), the Department of Energy (DOE), the Army Corps of Engineers and other federal, state and local authorities.

    Transmission rates, tariffs and terms of service are usually subject to regulation by the local state public utility commission (PUC), and the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC).

    Distribution (retail electrical service) rates are usually subject to regulation by the local state public utility commission (PUC). The FERC has no authority over retail pricing of electricity at the consumer level.

    A utility may not construct or incur financial commitments for construction of any substantial generating facilities or large capacity transmission lines without the prior approval of various state and federal government agencies. In addition, PUC's also regulate transactions between affiliates, transfers of certain facilities and issuance of securities.

    Has deregulation been successful within the United States? Competition is supposed to reduce prices if an unlimited number of producers can step into the market easily. However, in the electricity market, the cost to enter a market is high: the construction of an electricity generating facility is expensive and has a long lead time to obtain approval and then be constructed.




    Federal Power Act (16 U.S.C. 791-828c; Chapter 285, June 10, 1920; 41 Stat. 1063; as amended 1935)
  • Created the Federal Power Commission (FPC), which is now known as the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) after a reorganization in 1977, and was authorized to regulate rates and charges for interstate wholesale electric sales.
  • Authorizes the FERC to issue exemptions or licenses to construct, operate and maintain dams, water conduits, reservoirs, and transmission lines to improve navigation and to develop power from streams and other bodies of water over which it has jurisdiction as per 16 U.S.C. § 797(e).
  • Subsequently, the judical case of City of Colton v. SoCal Edison (1964), indicated that the FPC also has jurisdiction over intra-state sales of power that has been transmitted across state lines.

  • Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act of 1978 (PURA)
  • Required electric utilities to interconnect with and purchase power from certain cogeneration facilities and small power producers meeting the criteria for a qualifying facility (QF).
  • Specifically set forth criteria on who and what could qualify as QFs (mainly technological and size criteria). Two types of QFs were recognized: cogenerators, which sequentially produce electric energy and another form of energy (such as heat or steam) using the same fuel source, and small power producers, which use waste, renewable energy, or geothermal energy as a primary energy source.

  • Energy Policy Act of 1992 (EPACT 92)
  • Created a new category of power producers, called exempt wholesale generators (EWGs), which is an entity that directly, or indirectly through one or more affiliates, owned or operated facilities dedicated exclusively to producing electric power for sale in wholesale markets.
  • Expanded FERC's authority to order transmitting utilities to provide transmission service for wholesale power transmission to any electric utility, Federal power marketing agency, or any person generating electric energy in wholesale electricity markets (allowed independent power producers equal access to the utilities' transmission grid).
  • Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) Order No. 888 (Promoting Wholesale Competition Through Open Access Non-Discriminatory Transmission Services by Public Utilities; FERC Stats. & Regs. ¶31,036; 1996), as amended
  • Requires transmission owners who purchase transmission service to offer nondiscriminatory, comparable transmission service to others seeking such services over its own facilities. This often is referred to as the "open access" rule.
  • Ensures that potential suppliers of electricity will also have equal access to the market.
  • Encouraged the creation of a separate Price Exchange to reveal market-clearing prices for electricity in the new competitive market.
  • Promoted the concept of an Independent System Operator (ISO) as one way for existing tight power pools to satisfy the requirement of providing non-discriminatory access to transmission.
  • www.ferc.gov/legal/maj-ord-reg/land-docs/order888.asp
  • Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) Order No. 2000 (1999)
  • Encouraged the voluntary formation of Regional Transmission Organizations (RTO) to administer the transmission grid on a regional basis throughout North America (including Canada) by establishing the guidelines that a transmission entity must meet in order to qualify as an RTO (replaced state control and operation of the transmission grid).
  • www.ferc.gov/legal/maj-ord-reg/land-docs/RM99-2A.pdf

  • Energy Policy Act of 2005 (EPACT 05)
  • Authorizes FERC to certify an Electric Reliability Organization (ERO) to propose and enforce reliability standards for the bulk power system and authorized penalties for violation of these mandatory standards.
  • Authorizes the Secretary of Energy to conduct a study of electricity congestion within one year of the enactment of the Energy Policy Act, and every three years thereafter.
  • Authorizes the Secretary of Energy to designate "National Interest Electric Transmission Corridors" based on these congestion studies.
  • Requires FERC to establish incentive-based rate treatments for public utilities' transmission infrastructure in order to promote capital investment in facilities for the transmission of electricity, attract new investment with an attractive return on equity, encourage improvement in transmission technology, and allow for the recovery of prudently incurred costs related to reliability and improved transmission infrastructure.
  • Permits FERC to terminate, prospectively, the obligation of electric utilities to buy power from QFs, such as industrial cogenerators. FERC may do so when the QFs in the relevant area have adequate opportunities to make competitive sales, as defined by EPACT 2005.
  • Repeals PUHCA 1935 and replaces it with new PUHCA 2005, which provides FERC and state access to books and records of holding companies and their members and provides that certain holding companies or states may obtain FERC-authorized cost allocations for non-power goods or services provided by an associate company to public utility members in the holding company.
  • www.doi.gov/iepa/EnergyPolicyActof2005.pdf   (.pdf format)

  • European Union

    The Energy Community Treaty became effective July 2006.


    Spain

    Electricity pricing (tariffs) is heavily regulated in Spain such that the generating companie sell it at a price below the cost of actual production, even while consumption has been increasing. The Spanish National Energy Commission (CNE) reported in 2008 that the government subsidized deficit amounted to €14 billion in fiscal 2008.



      Wholesale Electrical Power Pricing & Electricity Trading
     

    U.S. Wholesale Electricity Market

    A power company is a base load (cumulative electric demand of a geographic area or an electric utility, usually measured in megawatts) serving entity, which means that it has to have sufficient electric power to provide service to its customers (load balance or supply equals demand). If the entity has a problem with a generator that goes off-line or there is greater demand than had been anticipated then the entity has a short-term balancing of base load requirement (needs additional electricity or balancing the load so that supply will equal demand). The requiement could be hourly or daily and may require spot purchase or negotiating a longer-term energy supply contract (Power Purchase Agreement / PPA).

    Each one of the NERC reliability councils, ISO / RTO operators and several private operators represent an electricity trading hub / delivery point. Power plants and utilities operating within a regional transmission reliability organization often work together to create a power pool of available wholesale electricity (all of the power plants are indirectly connected to each other through the regional transmission grid and neighboring regional grid).

    In the United States, the wholesale electricity market is a pool-based, short-term electricity market coordinated by a system operator for the sale of electricity generated by a power plant / utility to another utility, trader, supplier, aggregator or marketer. There are several types of transactions in the wholesale market:

  • Bilateral contract, which is usually a medium- or long-term contract for generation between power producers and utilities for any electricity wattage amount and price that the wholesale parties agree on in order for the utility to meet daily minimum base load or for a supplier to honr a delivery contract; the contract can also be cleared by one of the exchanges.


  • The Day-Ahead Market, which is an auction market where electric power generators, load serving entities, and traders / brokers bid and offer electricity for every hour of the next day in a short-term forward market. In the United States, the day-ahead market is managed by each regional ISO for its respective system. All power plant offers to sell electricity for next day delivery within the ISO are ranked by price, from lowest to highest. Starting with the lowest-priced plant's offer, subsequent offers are selected in sequence until sufficient supply is committed to obtain load balance (the market closes with the ISO's acceptance of the final day-ahead schedule price). The last plant's offer chosen (to obtain load balance) sets the wholesale clearing price. All power plants that offer their electricity at or below the clearing price are scheduled to operate and earn the clearing price for their electricity production. Those that offered too high are not selected to run (which means that the generating facility may have idle capacity thus creating a built-in incentive not to overbid). Thus, the day-ahead market allows market participants to secure prices the day before the operating day and hedge against price fluctuations that can occur in real time as the spot market for electricity has the most price volatility. The selection of offers must also factor in transmission constraints and potential outages. However, some critics complain that the ISO single-price power auction has resulted in supply that is much more expensive than it should be as the clearing price becomes retroactive to all those participants who were willing to take a lower price.


  • Spot Market, which is the real-time immediate purchase and delivery of electrical power if a participant still has an insufficient electric power supply even after their own generating capacity, long-term bilateral contract delivery and the day-ahead market.


  • Intra-day Market, which is the anonymous, continuous trading of electricity up to one hour before the actual hour of operation.


  • In addition, after a utility / supplier / marketer has purchased electric power to serve their load requirement, they also have to meet strict scheduling requirements and timelines in order to make sure that the power is transmitted to the correct destination at the correct time. In the United States, the ISOs and RTOs listed above are the entities that operate the wholesale electricity market and administer the transmission grid within their respective territory but there are many other participants involved.

    For instance, two power generators, or a generator and a utility or a generator and a supplier can enter into a bilateral, over-the-counter (OTC) contract, which specifies a defined quantity (electricity is all of the same "quality" as long as it maintains a steady voltage and frequency) has been sold by one party to another at a particular commercial node, zone or hub. All of these parties can also purchase electricity on a electric power exchange (see below). Throughout any single day, the wholesale price of electricity on the electric power grid reflects the real-time availablity and demand for electricity.

    A Load Forecast Analyst (LFA) employed by a power generating company or distributor attempts to forecast all of its customer’s loads in their respective ISO / RTO Day Ahead Market. The forecast is based on developing a historical model of "day type" (predominant weather conditions during the day, which includes temperature, HDD, CDD, and precipitation) and demand during the day type by hour (every electricity market has a historical minimum base load and peak load; most markets have summer peak load, which can be as much as 3.5X minimum load), and then forecasting as to whether a similar "day type" is approaching and whether there will be any variance to the predictive model. Based on the forecast, the company will determine if it needs to purchase additional electricity to balance the load or whether it has excess electricity that it can sell.

    Peak demand is usually highest in the afternoon and early evening (electricity usage is at a peak because it is the point when most people are awake, working or active, and then lights are turned on as the sundown approaches; Summer Peak means the addition of air conditioners being turned on), which means that prices are also higher at these times. There are several clearly identifiable points during a 24-hour period for which additional electricity may be required: morning peak, afternoon peak, evening peak, and off-peak. Off-peak hours are usually defined as an 8-hour evening period Monday through Friday, and then all hours on Saturday, Sunday and Federal holidays. Generating facilities, transmission facilities and distributors also sometimes have to purchase electricity to meet contingency reserve requirements (as high as 15.0% of base load).

    Interstate sales of electricity on the wholesale market and by public utilities (investor-owned utilities, power marketers, independent power producers, and non-exempt electric cooperatives) are subject to regulation by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC).

    Aggregation, in the wholesale market, means that a trader attempts to amass a volume of electricity from several different sources in order to create a larger package.


    Electricity Pricing

    The primary factor that influences the price of electricity is the cost and availability of fuel used for power generation and the cost of transmission necessary to deliver the electricity (tariffs).

    As indicated above, the cost to generate electricity fluctuates daily and monthly depending on the mix of fuel, and when it was purchased, used by the generating facility. Overall, the long-term trend has been that electricity prices are increasing because fuel costs have been increasing: Coal price has increased from a 1999 average of $1.22 per Million Btu to $2.07 in 2008; Distillate fuel (No. 2) has increased from a 1999 average of $4.03 per Million Btu to $20.08 in 2008; Natual gas has increased from a 1999 average of $2.57 per Million Btu to $9.11 in 2008. In addition, natural gas prices have a greater impact on electricity prices as gas-fired generators are often used to generate peak demand load and these generators set the prices for a large percentage of the time in many short-term or spot purchased power markets. The prospects for new baseload coal plants being constructed is declining, and new baseload plants may wind up being natural gas-fired plants, which will add further demand on natural gas supplies and fuel pricing.

    There is no specific type or brand that can differentiate electricity: once it is generated there are no identifying features to indicate the source (some utilities and marketers charge a premium at the retail level for electricity generated from "renewable" sources).

    In the wholesale electricity market, the two most important factors that influence price at any given time are:
  • Supply / Avaliability - if a generating facility must perform immediate maintenance on a generator, or the generator is shut down through an operating mlafunction then that facility cannot supply the amount of electricity that had been contracted for by a utility, supplier or grid operator who, in turn, may have to go into the market to purchase additional electric power to meet base load demand; or the generating facility itself may have to go into the market to purchase additional electric power to meet contractual delivery requirements.
  • Weather - if the temperature of a Summer day is hotter than had been forecasted and there is additional demand for electric power to operate air conditioners than had been projected then the utility may have to purchase additional electricity immediately to meet the load demand. Conversely, if the day's temperature is cooler than had been forecasted, and there is less demand for electricity, then the generating facility, supplier or utility may have excess electricity being generated or being delivered that could be sold to another party.
  • Day-ahead markets for delivery pricing include (all markets have an On-Peak and Off-Peak; prices are $/MWh):
     
    ERCOT
  • ERCOT
  • ERCOT, North
  • ERCOT, Houston
  • ERCOT, West
  • ERCOT, South
  •  
    Southeast
  • VACAR
  • Southern, into
  • Florida
  • TVA, into
  • Entergy, into
  •  
    West
  • COB
  • Mid-C
  • Palo Verde
  • Mead
  • Mona
  • Four Corners
  • NP15
  • SP15
  •  
    Northeast
  • Mass Hub
  • NY Zone G
  • NY Zone J
  • NY Zone A
  • Otario
  •  
    PJM
  • PJM West
  • Dominion Hub
  • AD Hub
  • NI Hub
  •  
    MISO
  • Michigan Hub
  • First Energy Hub
  • Cinergy Hub
  • Illinois Hub
  • Minnesota Hub
  •  
    SPP
  • SPP, North
  • In the United States, the Intercontinental Exchange (ICE) exchange also offers over-the-counter (OTC) trading in Day Ahead markets in North American power.



    Electric Power Exchanges & Electricity Trading

    As indicated above, the several Regional Transmission Organizations (RTO) / Independent System Operators (ISO) operate realtime (spot) power markets (wholesale bulk power generation and transmission). Some also operate day-ahead markets.
  • California ISO (CASIO)
  • Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT ISO)
  • ISO New England (ISO-NE)
  • Midwest ISO (MISO ISO)
  • Mid-Continent Area Power Pool (MAPP)
  • New York ISO (NYISO)
  • PJM Interconnection (PJM)
  • Southwest Power Pool, Inc. (SPP)
  • Austria: Energy Exchange Austria (EXAA), offers spot market; spot market CO2; Clearing is handled by OeKB (Oesterreichische Kontrollbank AG).

    Belgium: Belpex (Belgian Power Exchange), offers day ahead market (continuous day-ahead, intraday power market and green energy certificates exchange is scheduled in 2008).

    Benelux: European Energy Derivatives Exchange N.V. (ENDEX), offers Dutch and Belgian power contracts.

    Germany: European Energy Exchange AG (EEX) includes EEX Power Spot, EEX Spot Markets and EEX Derivatives Market.

    India: Indian Energy Exchange (IEX), offers day ahead market with double-sided closed, hourly and block order, scheduling and transmission capacity reservation support, daily settlement and secured payment; Operated by Financial Technologies (FTIL) and Power Trading Corporation (PTC).

    Italy: Gestore Mercato Elettrico (GME), offers day ahead market; adjustment market; ancillary services market.

    Netherlands: APX Power NL offers day ahead market; intraday market; Strips market.

    Norway: Nord Pool ASA (Nordic Power Exchange) is owned by the two national grid companies, Statnett SF in Norway (50%) and Affärsverket Svenska Kraftnät in Sweden (50%), and offers hourly (Elspot) and continuous power trading 24 hours a day, 7 days a week covering individual hours, up to one hour prior to delivery (Elbas).

  • The traded products are one-hour long power contracts (the Elspot and Elbas physical market products are traded on Nord Pool Spot).
  • Elbas is the internest-based Intra-day Market, which is the anonymous, continuous trading of electricity up to one hour before the actual hour of operation.
  • Nord Pool Clearing ASA (NPC) is the central counterparty for trading and clearing of Nordic, German and Dutch financial power derivatives, financial carbon derivatives, and spot carbon contracts (owned and managed by NASDAQ OMX Commodities).
  • SESAM is the trading system used by Nord Pool Spot for auction trading of physical delivery day-ahead power contracts.
  • At the border between Germany and Jutland, the German TSO (E.ON Netz) and the Danish TSO (Energinet.dk) operate a joint auction for north / south capacity. Nordpool's price quotation in Germany is KONTEK.
  • On December 17, 2009, the daily price in 5 out of 7 price areas on Nord Pool Spot was above 250 EUR/MWh, and during the two hour trading session between 16:00 (4:00pm) and 18 (6:00pm) the spot price was at a record 1,400 EUR/MWh. The reason for the run up in the price(s) was due to an outage at Swedish nuclear power plants in combination with increased consumption due to cold weather.
  • United Kingdom: APX Power UK offers futures market; day ahead market; intraday market; half hour, 2 hour 4 hour blocks; rolling 2 days; rolling 7 days; clearing services for the APX Power UK Spot Carbon contract.

    United States: The Energy Authority is the trading platform used by 39 public power utilities in the U.S., and provides hourly bilateral trading, day-ahead and Term bilateral trading, forward bilateral trading.





    Wholesale Electric Power Marketers / Electricity Traders

    Wholesale power marketers take title to deregulated, wholesale electric power from electric power generators and then offer to sell such electric power directly to other utilities or to retailers (they also assist companies that generate electricity to market their electricity). These companies are also known as Aggregators, which are electric power traders who want to locate both supply and demand customers to create a load, purchase power in bulk, and earn a commission or spread on the sale.

    A wholesale marketer can also be an unregulated subsidiary of a electricity generating company.







      Electricity Futures Market
     

    United States

    The central issue with regard to a futures market for electrical power delivery is that electricity is a commodity that cannot be stored. Rather, electricity must be generated at approximately the same time it is being consumed.

    In the United States, electricity futures contracts are quoted and traded on the CME Group member exchange New York Mercantile Exchange / NYMEX (open outcry / pit trading); CME ClearPort (traded off-exchange for clearing only). The PJM Western Hub Peak Calendar Month Real Time LMP Swap futures contract offers opportunities for risk management of electricity pricing in the Midwest, New York State, and other areas in the mid-Atlantic states.

  • Product Symbol L1
  • Contract size is 80 Megawatt hours (MWh) (5 MW per peak hour)
  • Floating Price for each contract month will be equal to the arithmetic average of the PJM Western Hub Real-Time LMP for peak hours provided by PJM Interconnection, LLC (PJM) for the contract month
  • Price is quoted in U.S. dollars and cents per MWH
  • Minimum Fluctuation $0.05 per MWH
  • Peak Days “Peak day” shall mean a Monday through Friday, excluding North American Electric Reliability Corporation holidays
  • Peak Hours From Hour Ending (HE) 0800 Eastern Prevailing Time (EPT) through HE 2300 EPT
  • Trading shall cease on the last business day of the contract month
  • Open Outcry trading hours: Monday – Friday 9:00 AM to 2:30 PM (8:00 AM to 1:30 PM CT)
  • Settlement Type Financial
  • The CME Group / New York Mercantile Exchange (NYMEX) ClearPort platform also provides traders with the opportunity to purchase and sell electricity contracts in units of dollars and cents per megawatt hour off the exchange (but clear them through the exchange through ClearPort). These electricity futures contracts are not for fixed quantities because the number of on-peak and off-peak hours can vary from month to month. Thus, the total quantities of power represented by most of the electricity contracts are variable.

    The contracts are for the on-peak and off-peak periods as defined by the North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC), the power industry’s operations coordinating group. The electricity is from Regional Transmission Organizations (RTO) / Independent System Operators (ISO).

    The contracts include peak and off-peak monthly futures for the
  • PJM Interconnection western hub
  • AEP-Dayton Hub
  • Northern Illinois Hub
  • New York Independent System Operator Zone A (western New York)
  • NYISO Zone G (Hudson Valley)
  • NYISO Zone J (New York City)
  • New England Internal Hub
  • Midwest Independent Transmission System Operator Cinergy
  • Michigan Hub
  • Illinois Hub
  • Minnesota Hub
  • Electricity Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT)
  • Daily futures contracts are also available for the
  • PJM Interconnection western hub
  • NYISO Zones A, G, and J
  • ISO New England
  • AEP-Dayton Hub
  • Cinergy Hub
  • Northern Illinois Hub
  • ERCOT
  • Futures contracts also listed for western locations are the
  • Dow Jones Mid-Columbia Electricity Price Index futures
  • Dow Jones North Path-15 Electricity Price Index futures
  • Dow Jones Palo Verde Electricity Price Index futures
  • Dow Jones South Path-15 Electricity Price Index futures
  • Monthly electricity options contracts are listed for PJM, ISO-New England, AEP Dayton, Cinergy and Northern Illinois.

    U.S. Hub Price Indexes include
  • California/Oregon Border Electricity Prices (COB)
  • Cinergy Electricity Price Index (CINERGY)
  • Four Corner Electricity Index symbols (4CORNER)
  • Mead Market Place (MEAD)
  • Mid Columbia Price Indexes (MID)
  • NP15 Index (NP15)
  • Palo Verde Electricity Indexes (PALO)
  • Pennsylvania/New Jersey/Maryland Electricity Index (PJM)
  • SP15 Index (SP15)
  • In the United States, the Nodal Exchange offers cash settled, on-peak and off-peak contracts for locational marginal price (LMP) of power determined in the day-ahead markets for each Node in the participant ISOs and RTOs.
  • Electronic trading platform only
  • ISO and RTO nodes offered include Midwest ISO (MISO), New England ISO (NE-ISO), New York ISO (NYISO), PJM.
  • Contract units are 1 MW x hrs/month
  • Trading hours are Monday – Friday, 9:00am – 4:00pm Eastern.
  • Auction window hours are Monday – Friday, 11:00am – 1:00pm Eastern
  • Contracts are cleared through LCH.Clearnet using SunGard’s GMI platform
  • Bilateral trades of contracts can also be submitted for clearing

  • Europe

    European Price Indexes include
  • Amsterdam Power Exchange Daily Spot Market Index (APX)
  • GPI Index: EUR and USD (USD)
  • Norway Sweden 52 Week Index (NSE)
  • Select Power Index
  • Spanish Pool
  • Swiss Electricity Price Index (SWEP)
  • Zeebrugge Gas Index (ZIG)

  • Australia

    The d-cyphaTrade ASX Australian Electricity Futures and Options contracts are traded on the Australian Securities Exchange (ASX).




      Wind Power
     

    Please see the separate page on  Wind Power Industry and Market.



      Solar Power
     

    Please see the separate page on  Solar Power Industry and Market.



      Ocean Generated / Wave & Tidal Power
     

    Ocean generated power refers to equipment either floating on or submersed below the ocean's surface, which use the physical movement from waves or tide level to generate electricity.

    One design of wave power generation utilizes a modular, ocean-going buoy, which rises and falls with the waves, which in turn moves hydraulic fluid within the buoy. The motion of the hydraulic fluid is used to pump a generator, and the electricity is then transmitted to shore over a submerged transmission line.

    One design of tidal power generation utilizes the flow velocity of the tide by placing an upright structure within a bay or estuary area. The structure contains an axial turbine that will turn in either direction in which the tide is moving, and the electricity is then transmitted to shore over a submerged transmission line. The tide is a very predictable source however it needs to have a strong enough flow to make the turbine revolve.




      Nuclear Power
     

      CME Group / NYMEX Uranium U308 Futures Contract

    There are 104 nuclear reactor powered electricity generating facilities in the United States, which supply approximately 5.0% of the electricity generated in the U.S. Nuclear reactors are especially desirable because:

  • As base load generators they can operate 24 hours a day / 7 days a week.
  • The nuclear reactor powered facility does not have the carbon dioxide, sulfur dioxide or any greenhouse gas emission problem that fossil fuel powered facilities have.
  • The cost of electricity produced by nuclear plants in the United States is low (1.68 cents per kilowatt-hour in 2007).
  • The Nuclear Energy Institute indicates that U.S. nuclear power electricity production generated a record 806 billion kWh (approximate) in 2007.

    The Nuclear Energy Institute further indicates that the nation of France as the highest percentage of electrical power produced by nuclear reactor powered generating facilities: 59 facilities produce approximately on average 78.0% of France's electricity supply. South Korea has the second highest concentration: 19 facilities produce approximately on average 40.0% of the nation's electricity supply.

    The International Energy Agency (IEA) OECD Electricity Production by Fuel Type Report indicates that within the OECD for the nine months ending September 30, 2009:
  • Nuclear reactor powered electricity generation accounted for 75.7% of total electricity production in France.
  • 52.7% in Belgium
  • 34.0% in Finland
  • 36.6% in Switzerland
  • 34.1% in South Korea
  • 26.9% in Japan
  • 22.4% in Germany
  • 20.1% in the United States
  • 17.4% in the United Kingdom
  • 14.7% in Canada
  • Quite a number of nuclear reactors operating within the United Kingdom were constructed during the 1950s, and nuclear reactors of the Magnox design (11 stations) are now obsolete and being decommissioned. A number of the newer gas cooled design nuclear reactors are then secheduled to commence decommission in 2015.   www.nda.gov.uk/

    The most simple description of the operation of a nuclear reactor powered electricity generating facility is that heat is released from the controlled decay of U-235 (enriched uranium) within the reactor infrastructure. The controlled chain reaction is known as nuclear fission, which means that the uranium nuclei separates when bombarded with neutrons. As the nuclei separates the neutrons released bombard another uranium atom causing another decay / separation, and as the self-perpetuting chain reaction continues the heat is released during the separation of the nuclei. The chain reaction continues until the uranium is depleted (there are insufficient neutrons remaining to keep the process going thus new uranium fuel must be added to the reactor; fuel rods need to be replaced in approximately 18 months). That heat is used to turn water into super-heated, pressurized steam, which is then applied to the fan blades of the turbine, which then revolves the shaft / rotor to generate electricity.

    Only Pressurized Water Reactors (PWRs) and Boiling Water Reactors (BWRs) are in commercial operation in the United States. These plants have been operating for just over 2 decades now without a serious problem occurring. The problem with nuclear reactors though is the potential for a melt down, gas release or explosion that would contaminate the surrounding countryside with radioactive material. The second major problem is the storage of nuclear waste literally for thousands of years. It also takes time and a substantial investment to construct a nuclear power facility (the last large nuclear reactor project constructed in the United States was in 1996).

    The most serious problem in the United States with regard to a nuclear reactor powered generating facility was at Three Mile Island in 1979 when a reactor failed and there was radiation leakage within a containment building.

    Nuclear waste (depleted uranium from spent fuel rods) can be reprocessed to extract uranium and plutonium that can be utilized for energy or medical application.

    In response to the increased interest in nuclear power, there has been the proposal for the authorization of mini-reactors that are constructed in a factory and then brought to a site as a less expensive alternative than the standard 1,000 Megawatt structure. Rather, the introduction of a 25 to 125 Megawatt, Light Water Reactor nuclear power plant is being propsed as a path for the United States to increase electricty generating capacity (a 45 Megawatt unit is estimated sufficient to generate electicity to power approximately 45,000 U.S. residences). Not only is money saved in the construction process but the units will also utilize standard steam turbines, generators and condensers, which reduces costs in the manufacturing process. Another advantage is that several units could also be linked together to increase baseload generating capacity. (No commercial mini-reactors are presently in operation in the United States as they have not been certified by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission).

    In 2007, NRG Energy applied for a license with the Nuclear Regulatory Commission to construct a new nuclear reactor powered electricity generation facility.

    In response to the renewed interest and promotion of nuclear power as a "clean" alternative to coal fired plants, the price of uranium (U308; concentrated uranium oxide produced from uranium ore, also known as yellowcake) has been increasing steadily over the past few years. The price has increased from a low of $10.30 per pound in January 2003 to $84.00 per pound as of October 2007, touching a high of $138.00 per pound in July 2007. The primary sources for newly mined uranium (U-238) are Canada, Russia and Australia.


    Nuclear power manufacturing / generating companies:



    Locations of Operating Nuclear Power Reactors in the United States   www.nrc.gov/info-finder/reactor/

    New Reactor Regulation (NRC)   www.nrc.gov/reactors/new-reactors.html

    New Reactor Licensing Applications   www.nrc.gov/reactors/new-licensing/new-licensing-files/new-rx-licensing-app-legend.pdf




      Distributed Generation
     

    Distributed Generation (also referred to as on-site generation or dispersed generation) means that small electricity producing generators are located near power consumption. Grid-connected photovoltaic and wind electricity generating systems located on commercial and residential properties allow these properties / buildings to become electricity providers to the local / regional electrical grid network. As indicated above, the conventional infrastructure for electricity generation is that a large generating plant produces a large volume (gigawatts) of electricity and then transmits the electricity for widespread distribution. Distributed generation reverses that concept by allowing small electricity generating equipment (residential / commercial real estate PV system, residential wind turbine, residential / commercial real estate fuel cell, natural gas / propane microturbine, small commercial solar park / wind turbine park) to either provide some of the electricity (kW to MW) consumed by the residential or commercial property, or transmit into the grid from the distribution edge, usually through the stimulus of a feed-in-tarrif or net metering agreement.

    The growth of distributed generation is a potential threat to the base rate of generating companies / utilities. In response, some companies are trying to own the renewable energy / distributed energy generating capacity. One way is to offer solar panels to eligible customers on a common feeder line. The customer has no upfront fee as the company employs the contractor to conduct the physical assessment of the customer's property and if roof direction, age and structural integrity is acceptable then the company installs the equipment and the customer signs an easement, allowing the company access for panel installation and maintenance. The customer then pays for the electricity at a community rate, which is lower than the base rate. This way the company fulfills the requirement to increase capacity from a renewable energy source but retain ownership of the infrastructure and retain pricing control. Another alternative is to eliminate utility incentive payments and price supports to private installers and customers and have the utility use those funds to complete a widespread installation of PV systems within municipal areas on residential and commercial real estate rooftops, public buildings rooftops, schhols and campus rooftops, parking lots and unused rights of way. However, in March 2009, voters in California defeated Measure B, which would have allowed the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power to commence such a program, in the belief that private competition would keep installation prices down and challenge any monopoly the utility would have over electricity generation and pricing.

    Overall, distributed generation does increase capacity, especially during peak demand hours. However, due to the solar and wind power's intermittent generation problem there will always have to be a conventional base load electricity generating capability.



      Consumers / Retail Market
     
    A 100 watt incandescent light bulb burning for 10 hours uses one kilowatthour. The average U.S. residential base retail price per kilowatthour in 2008 was 11.36 cents/kWh. Thus, a U.S. consumer could light a room for 10 hours per day on average for 11.36 cents, $3.41 for a 30-day month, and $41.46 for the 365-day year in 2008.

    In a 30-day month there are 720 hours (30 x 24). If a 100 watt incandescent light bulb was left burning all day for the 30-day month period it would amount to 72 kWh (2.4 kWh per day x 30), which would cost on average $8.18 for the month (72 x 11.36, then divided by 100) in 2008.

    A large, 1,500 watt window-mounted air conditioner unit consumes 1,500 watts per hour (1.5 kWh), which means it would cost on average 17.04 cents per hour (1.5 x 11.36) to operate the air conditioner in 2008.

    In a 30-day month there are 720 hours (30 x 24). If a 25 watt incandescent light bulb was left burning all day for the 30-day month period it would amount to 18 kWh (0.6 kWh per day x 30), which would cost on average $2.05 for the month (18 x 11.36, then divided by 100) in 2008.

    In 2007, electricity sales totaled approximately 3,765 Billion Kilowatthours (kWh) in the United States. Use of electricity for each of the major consuming sectors:

  • Residential 37% (single-familiy and multi-family buildings)
  • Commercial 36% (retail, wholesale, restaturants, hotel, motel, offices, hospitals, medical, educational institutions, government)
  • Industrial 27% (manufacturing, construction, mining, agriculture)
  • Transportation less than 1.0% (primarily railroads, railways)
  • The Energy Information Administration (U.S. Department of Energy) indicates that in 2007 in the United States, the average monthly residential electricity consumption was 936 kilowatthours (kWh).

    The Energy Information Administration (U.S. Department of Energy) has indicated that U.S. electricity consumption is projected to increase at an annual average rate of 1.50% through 2030 (approximately 30% in the next 2 decades). Residential, retail consumers have steadily shifted electricity consumption away from space heating and water heating toward appliances, consumer electronics / personal digital appliances and air conditioning. However, the demand for electric power has not translated directly into higher household expenditures as household income growth has outpaced the price increase in electricity.

    In the United States, deregulation of the electricity utility industry means that the consumer is supposed to have an opportunity to select an electric power provider from among public and private power companies, cooperatives, energy supply companies (ESCOs) and retail energy marketers (REMs). Consumers are divided into residential, commercial and industrial (and large commercial and large industrial). Historically, retail electricity rates had been based on the cost of providing traditional bundled electric service: the combination of transmission, distribution and generation services. Deregulation resulted that many operators had to "unbundle" services. This has meant that prices are now cost-based rates for transmission and distribution services (and also market pricing for generation services; utilities may own separate generating, transmission and distribution business operations). In deregulated states, base rates were capped during a period of transition.

    In the United States, most retail residential consumers purchase electrical power from a local utility, distribution company or retail service provider. These retailers can be a not-for-profit municipal entity, an electric co-operative owned by its members, a private, for-profit company owned by stockholders (often called an investor-owned utility / IOU), or a power marketer (purchase wholesale power but owns no generation, transmission or distribution infrastructure).

  • In the United States, retail pricing to residential customers usully includes a base charge price per KWh for the first 500 kWh to 1,000 kWh, and then a higher charge per kWh for any additional consumption after the first 1,000 kWh.
  • Many utilities also added a fuel charge during 2008 when fuel costs increased substantially.
  • Some utilities do offer a lower per kWh charge in the evenings in order to induce consumers to move consumption (for instance, laundry machines) outside of the high demand daytime hours.
  • In many deregulated states, monthly utility billing has been divided into two charges, Delivery / Distribution Services and Commodity / Supplier Services, in order to make it easier for customers to select a separate electricity supplier and see the actual per kWh cost of the power only.
  • The Supplier service may also be sub-divided into Basic Service or Competitive Power Supply. Basic pricing may include a six-month fixed price or a monthly variable price.
  • Delivery / Distribution service remains a monopoly service provided exclusively to customers in a particular service territory by the local electric utility company, and rates for Distribution Service continue to be fully regulated in most locations.
  • There may also be a Transmission Service charge, which is the cost of electricity transmission across the regional grid and is passed on to the consumer. Retail transmission rates continue to be fully regulated in most locations but the structure of the expense essentially allows each utility / distributor the opportunity to recover this operating costs it incurs.
  • Regulated utilities may not unilaterally increase retail rates to consumers. Rather, the utility must apply to the local public utility commission (regulatory agency) and file a rate case in order to increase rates to recover the costs of delivering electricity. A public hearing is usually held prior to the regulatory agency making a decision.

    A gasoline-, diesel or natural gas-powered generator can be used to power all or a portion of a residential household load (usually used as a backup electricity source). A generator transfer switch is needed for individuals who wish to use an electric generator as a source of backup power for a home (or even a business). The switch literally switches the power source from the commercial power supply company to the local generator. The use of an independent generator is only viable based on the availability and price of the fuel source used to operate the generator.


    CFL (Compact Fluorescent Light)

    Internationally, consumers are being asked to no longer purchase and use incandescent light bulbs but now use spiral / compact fluorescent light bulbs / CFL and sub-compact CFL (the U.S. Congress passed legislation eliminating the usage of incandescent light bulbs by 2014). The fluorescent bulbs are promoted as utilizing less energy to operate and last longer than the traditional incandescent light bulb. One of the problems recently reported related to the spiral fluorescent light bulb is that they contain several milligrams of mercury as part of their construction. Hence, these light bulbs will require a planned recycling program for disposal rather than have them merely placed into general trash collection as incandescent light bulbs were in the past. Similarly, consumers need to be more cautious when cleaning up a broken spiral fluorescent light bulb.

    A recent report issued by OSRAM GmbH (a company that manufactures lighting products) indicated that the next generation of Light Emitting Diode (LED) light bulbs provided real energy savings (presently 5x more efficient than incandescent lamps as less energy is required to manufacture the bulb and the bulbs function longer than the standard incandescent bulb).
    OSRAM LED Life-cycle Assessment Report


    Electric Automobiles

    If electric (battery operated) automobiles become the primary automotive design in order to reduce carbon emissions and petroleum fuel dependancy then additional electicity generating capacity will be required to meet this new demand for automobile charging stations (either in the home and rental apartment or public streets and roads, or both). There are two types of automobile chargers. The Level 1 charger has a 120 volt outlet and the Level 2 charger has a 220 / 240 volt outlet. Both outlest require special cable that have to be connected to the automobile. The existing 8- to 10-kilowatt automobile battery requires approximately 6 to 8 hours to be recharged by the Level 1 charger and approximately 3 to 4 hours by the Level 2 charger (also known as a quick charger, a dedicated 220 / 240 volt line has to be professionally installed, which has to be inspected by a city or state inspector).

    The battery size needs to be reduced in size and weight, and less expensive to manufacture: a lithium ion battery adds in excess of $10,000 to a manufacturer's cost. In addition, lithium ion batteries do not perform as well in cold weather as the cold termperature slows the chemical process of the battery.

    Some automobile models capture energy from the brakes to recharge the battery. However, this design can actually reduce the speed of the automobile simply by removing one's foot from the accelerator.




      Electicity Generating Industry and Electricity Markets Information & Research Resources
     

    American Public Power Association   www.appanet.org/

    American Wind Energy Association (AWEA)   www.awea.org/

    Asociación Española de la Industria Eléctrica (UNESA)   www.unesa.es/   (Spain)

    Council of European Energy Regulators (CEER)   www.energy-regulators.eu/

    Edison Electric Institutie (EEI)   www.eei.org/

    Electric Power Research Institutie (EPRI)   my.epri.com/

    Electric Power Supply Asociation (EPSA)   www.epsa.org/

    Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT) / Texas Regional Entity   www.ercot.com/

    Electricity Consumers Resource Council (ELCON)   www.elcon.org/

    Energy Information Administration (EIA)   www.eia.doe.gov/

    Energy Regulators Regional Association (ERRA)   www.erranet.org/

    Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC)   www.ferc.gov/

    Florida Reliability Coordinating Council (FRCC)   www.frcc.com/

    Industrial Energy Consumers of America (IECA)   www.ieca-us.com/

    Large Public Power Council (LPPC)   www.lppc.org/

    Midwest Reliability Organization (MRO)   www.midwestreliability.org/

    National Association of State Utility Consumer Advocates   www.nasuca.org/

    National Council on Electricity Policy   www.ncouncil.org/

    National Hydropower Association (NHA)   www.hydro.org/

    National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL), United States Solar Atlas   mapserve2.nrel.gov/website/L48NEWPVWATTS/viewer.htm

    National Rural Electric Cooperative Association (NRECA)   www.nreca.org/

    North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC)   www.nerc.com/

    Northeast Power Coordinating Council, Inc.   www.npcc.org/

    Nuclear Energy Institute   www.nei.org/

    ReliabilityFirst Corporation   www.rfirst.org/

    Southwest Power Pool, Inc.   www.spp.org/

    Western Electricity Coordinating Council   www.wecc.biz/

    U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy   www.eere.energy.gov/

    U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Nuclear Energy   www.nuclear.energy.gov/

    U.S. Department of Energy, Small Wind for Homeowners, Ranchers, and Small Businesses   www.windpoweringamerica.gov/small_wind.asp

    U.S. Department of Energy, U.S.-Canada Power System Outage Task Force, Final Report on the August 14, 2003 Blackout in the United States and Canada   reports.energy.gov/

    U.S. Department of Energy, Wind Powering America State Activities   www.windpoweringamerica.gov/state_activities.asp

    U.S. Department of Energy, Wind Resource Maps   www.windpoweringamerica.gov/wind_maps.asp

    U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission   www.nrc.gov/

    U.S. Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources   www.energy.senate.gov/public/

     



    Non-U.S. Electricity Regulatory Agencies

    Australia Energy Regulator (AER)   www.aer.gov.au/

    Canada Alberta Utilities Commission   www.auc.ab.ca/

    Brazil ANEEL (Agência Nacional de Energia Elétrica)   www.aneel.gov.br/

    New Zealand Electicity Commission   www.electricitycommission.govt.nz/

    Philippines Energy Regulatory Commission   www.erc.gov.ph/

     





    Return to Main Page


    Credit & Finance Risk Analysis

    Copyright © 2011 Credit and Finance Risk Analysis. All Rights Reserved.
    All corporate names and product names are the trademarks and/or registered trademarks of their respective owners.

    Bookmark and Share CredFinRisk.com